@Catphish37I'm ok with all your point, the positive and the negative. But for me this summary give me a very higher score. All the negative point are detail that can be correct in a near future. But the positive one need a lot of development. The game for me is a (9/10) and is fantastic.
@Mickstudio1308 Good for you. If they fix the issues, particularly the triple-bogey pickup, mouse swing, and sequential shooting in multiplayer, I'll give it a higher score. But as it stands right now, I'm done with the game. I'll watch the forums for a week or two to see if EA shows any interest in patching it but, if not, I'm moving on.
But this game is nowhere near a 9/10 right now by any objective measure. If you think it is, you're deluding yourself.
@Mickstudio1308I didn't say they don't show any interest. I said I'm waiting to see if they do.
If you're enjoying the game so much, great. Go and play it. No one needs you telling them to ignore their problems with it.
@Mickstudio1308I don't own 2k23. You don't need to understand the "hate". People have issues with the game, and they want to see them addressed. That's it. Simple.
You telling people who are already upset that they have no reason to be upset is only going to make them more upset.
@Mickstudio1308Because the negatives are really bad. They completely ruin the experience for me, and they *must* be addressed if I'm going to continue to play it.
Community ManagerHey, everyone. Let's keep in mind we all are going to have different opinions on what is important to us so let's keep our comments understanding and respectful of other's views.
Please keep the feedback coming! We all sincerely appreciate it.
@RickinWaStHonestly I play a lot to 2k23 and my personal opinion is that the graphic and all the motion of the swing is far behind EA game. When I play at 2k I always try to play real course of the pga tour, so I have enough of 30 course to play. I don't like the career in 2k because of the lack of authenticity, it's not the real tournament, it's not the real course, you don't have the real major. For someone like me that very like the realism the EA game is fantastic.
@RickinWaStFor me, what is making a great golf game, is the 5 positive point of @Catphish37.
1- Great graphic
2- Great gameplay
3- Great realism of the major and tournament
4- Great career mode
5- Great ambiance and sound effect
1. Remove the triple-bogey pickup.
2. Implement mouse swing.
3. Allow for turn-taking in multiplayer, at least in private matches.
My logic behind the ranking is this:
Right now, with the triple-bogey pickup in effect, I don't want to even play the game at all. It's sucked the authenticity right out of the experience. In truth, I haven't touched it since I discovered it. If they fix that, I would at least play it. Right now, in its current state, I think I'm done with it.
Mouse swing is a huge deal for me, and would make even just playing single-player so much more enjoyable. But it really needs to be an option for all modes (though I can understand an exception for ranked play).
Multiplayer is pointless to me and my friends if we all shoot simultaneous. Nobody likes it, nobody will play it. If they take care of the triple-bogey thing and mouse swing, I could at least enjoy single-player. If they do all three, I think I would be mostly satisfied with the game as a whole.
People are seriously stressing out on simutaneous play? Why? I'd rather not be limited by someone taking 50 years to make the shot and complete the hole then wait. I do agree that it should be an option.
Many are disturbed by the lack of turn based play, because that's how golf is played. EA puts all this effort into creating virtual representations of these golf courses yet it's not possible to play a normal game of golf with your friends online. Simultaneous play is not a normal game of golf. Turn based play should be the default. Simultaneous play should be an option. You might as well just play by yourself if everyone is just going to play through each other the entire round. And to each his own, but I have zero interest in seeing the ghost images of other golfers and their ball trails while I'm playing a given hole.
