Part 3. A very short and troubled development.
This is probably the most confusing part of bfn to find out: exactly just how long was the game in development?
Rumors of a gw3 popped up all the way back in mid 2018 with an Amazon comic book with very flimsy evidence but it still got attention.
After the walnut hills release in gw2 in mid 2019 a alpha for a new pvz game called picnic had surfaced but EA/popcap kept the game locked and quiet but leaks did squeeze out and well early reactions were very mixed. An alpha that started in early august released on September 4th with no real official beta? Not much time to improve is there?
Before bfn released it was revealed that their was a scrapped pve game and that the dev team than merged with the bfn dev team. Maybe this is why the pve feels like the most complete part of the game?
A fair amount of bfn's PvP maps are also taken from these pve areas so we're left with a feeling of copy pasted resources.
The concept art of bfn is also much smaller than either garden warfares and they seem mostly the same with the finished version.
I even did a post on this on these forums.
All of this leads to many believing that this game was rushed and developded in a small amount of time, most likely only 1 year.
Part 4. Founders and marketing: A broken start and a view of whats to come
So on september 4th bfn was revealed and this is where the problems start.
The game was available to play on the same day it was ANNOUNCED. There's no time for significant changes or improvements and there is no time for the new artstyle and gameplay systems to set in with fans.
Gw1 and gw2 had multiple trailers and dev commentary before and after launch while bfn only had its launch trailer than a handful of festive trailers on their youtube than nothing!
I myself only found out about the game because I looked it up and than got ONE 5 sec ad on youtube a few days later. If I wasn't such a Garden Warfare fan to begin with I would've never found or given this game a chance. In fact this genuinely isn't an opinion I share alone.
/
The early feedback was rather poor with many noticing flaws in balance, especially with nightcap, oak, superbrainz, and station. Bug reports also flowed in from many players and the massive change in gameplay formula was being noticed especially the upgrade system and sprinting. Snapdragon healed enemies lol.
Optimization was so terrible in founders to the point they had to reduce 12v12 turf to a 8v8 for a time and many reported issues.
The game quickly dropped in price and went on sale which is not a good sign for a game that costed less than gw2 did at launch.
Content slowly rolled out week by week but popcap failed to account for the fact that gamers would chew through the only available content open leading to many players already getting bored and burning out. This brings us to the next point.
Part 5: A shattered economy, painful grind, and the mad grab for rainbow stars.
Oh boy bfn's economy! Where to start on this absolute mess.
Look I don't want gw2's trillion reskins (ngl though some looked better than the og cosmetic) but bfn's economy crashed and burned within founders.
1. The removal of spawnables into cooldown resources has taken away the need to buy them to use in gameplay.
I understand some don't like the randomness of the sticker packs but we still could've reached a compromise of browncoats and pea cannons costing less than outhouse zombies and doom shrooms in guaranteed amounts by coins.
2. The reward o tron is a terrible system.
The new additions of emotes and text bubbles feel like they're in the reward o tron to make up for the lackluster amount of cosmetics.
Just 1 cosmetic or speech/text bubble costs 30,000 which will require the player to play about 2 games of turf or even more games of ops and team vanquish.
You dont even get to choose what you get so if you want a nice costume, TOO BAD here's a emote you'll never use!
Solo play has to be played on crazy in bfn to even earn the normal amount of coins and xp, why? Gw2 gave double on crazy so why change it for the worse? It just feels like you're punishing solo players.
3. Prize maps, bulbs, an annoying grind, and players already max leveling.
So to combat this lack of cosmetic content popcap introduced the prizemap a system that would give bulbs to buy items based on xp and this is all downhill from here.
15k xp for a single bulb, really? Players quickly burned through the ranking system and earned all the upgrades for there characters, even be able to buy more xp through coins allowing them to beat back the mass number they had accumulated.
However pocap than released the grandmaster rank to try and increase player numbers by getting max ranks to come back but what do you get for reaching max rank you ask?
"You get Nothing! You lose! Good day sir!"-willy wonka.
Thats right these new ranks were absolutely pointless and now without the variants you have only the same handful of characters to play (I'll get back to this later).
Now xp is only good for prize bulbs coming at an excruciatingly slow pace and since it's designed to give content over a month you're meant to be playing a few hours every day. Lets not forget that any exploits to speed up this process were hunted down by popcap and eliminated. The xp changes in bfn also don't favor healers so you're far better off earning xp through kills and the objective.
Now when new content came out like wizard prize bulbs were at their highest limit and if you missed him you would have to buy him for 500,000 now lets say your new to the game, ok? You know have to painfully slave away in multiplayer to finally unlock a new character. Same with wildflower and tv head.
They even had to lower the xp required for prize bulbs multiple times!
The switch allows players to work at their own pace on prize maps while any suckers stuck with console or pc will just have to WAIT an entire year before that specific map shows up again.
It was horrible when the game was still active because we never got confirmation that these would return creating a fomo system that preyed on your time!
At least challenges in GW2 give an XP Multiplier and it's a subtle lure into making you play along with multiplayer quests to earn coins faster while encouraging you to play more modes than just turf takeover.
4. Rainbow stars, oh boy.
New content is released but it's now in rux's store. Oh well you'll be able to earn rainbow stars freely through weekly modes which only reward so much per week that you'll have to play for months before you unlock one of these sparkly costumes.
Don't worry you can still BUY it with money if your worried you'll miss that outfit you like of course!
Oh but don't worry there's ranked battle arena which will give you 250 rainbow stars at the end of every season. That is of course if you win 75 matches in a row with no game disconnects, terrible teammates, your team leaving you, tryhard metalords that make the local gw1 super commando main look pathetic, afks, being stuck on plants, and lagging.
Not too mention that the gamemode was deader than a doornail during ranked so its no wonder the mode was pulled just like mixed modes.
They did give free rainbow stars out to players that played every few days but it WAS RANDOMIZED. Thats right if you wanted enough rainbow stars by playing the game well screw you heres only 25 while other people get 1000!
5. Nothing returns.
Gw1 and 2 had many cosmetics and taunts a gw3 could pull from but due to the shift to bfn with a artstyle change the cosmetics are all just thrown into the dumpster despite having the potential to stave off content cravings for a short time. Bummer.
No solo ops, really! Let's just talk about ops in general.
This game mode was absolutely OBLITERATED in bfn! We have less maps than gw1 to play it on, less positions to put the base, less pots, weaker pots, enemy variety is worse than gw1, boss variety has been cut down and there are few new ones that aren't from boss hunt, elite bosses are weak, death is meaningless since you just revive so your team feels no pressure in trying to revive you in time as you slowly go down one by one, the lack of elements like ice or toxic and the addition of upgrades means that healers are even more irrelevant as they dont have to act fast to save their team from being frozen or poisoned, its pathetically easy, ai seems worse, tv heads/wildflowers exist, no sense of emergency from the lack of an evacuation phase, and the pacing of the waves has been ruined.
The map design has also gotten much worse in bfn and there is no high ground verticality for the player or enemy classes like foot soldier to take advantage of in ops like crash course, sharkbite shores, or lunar landing. Invisble walls ewwww.
In short they simplified it, made it easy. So easy that nobody finds it fun anymore. People are just gonna play the older ops. Not only because they remember them, but because they're worth remembering in the first place.
Turf takeover. Only 4 points per map which is the lowest we have ever seen and the map design is rather poor with little vertical positions to use and a low amount of flank routes to take.
On consoles and pc it is the only mode on 12v12 in game therefore awarding the most xp so players will play them over ops or mixed modes.
A lot of the maps reuse concepts from gw1 such as preserve pastures being cactus canyon all over again or peachy district being walnut hills.
Defending/attacking is a nightmare due to the cramped nature of the points which require just 1 defender to completely stall the enemy team which is a step back from the gw system of needing more attackers than defenders on a smaller area.
Overtime doesn't end immediately after attackers are off the point which allows attackers to keep stalling by throwing bodies into the point to stall the game.
The progress bar is now decided by 1/3 intervals that go down if not completely captured.
Payload sections have the same problems cactus canyon and seeds of time had in spades with bombing the payload with everything a team has.
Bot ai gives up at the final objective so good luck solo players!
Defenders can almost never retake a point once forced out due to the narrow entryways back to the point.
The lack of teleporters has all but killed map pacing and flow as the sprint sections will be skipped if you die and walking to the next point from the last usually only takes 15 seconds after the first point and defenders are hardly ever given a good position to defend the base farther up the map like in gw1 and 2.
Depriving zombies of teles in gw1&2 left them at a major disadvantage as they now had to cross open terrain to the objective losing valuable time and being picked off by snipers. It was also a constant struggle to keep the teleporters up as they could be destroyed by defenders. This extra layer of combat strategy has been removed.
Spawn camping has now become an entirely new problem do to the awful overwatch style spawns that can be shot in and out of. Turning point is the worst culprit.
Furthermore, the sprint sections are nothing more than glorified set pieces as no combat happens in them and a defender staying back is guaranteed to get steamrolled in a heartbeat. They serve no purpose to the map. Sprinting feels like a feature that is only in the game due to pve having a large travel distance, not because the ttk and map flow is appropriately adjusted to it.
The finales are also horribly unbalanced like loggy acres or boring like tourist trap island.
The switch version reduced the mode down to 8v8 from being the only mode in bfn with 12v12 still.
Gnome bomb. Being able to see where the gnome will spawn is a good change but lets go over the negatives.
Part 6 continued
Sprinting absolutely DESTROYS the bomb carrier as he is unable to use abilities or sprint while having an icon that reveals his position to the entire enemy team. Loggy acres finale shares the same problem.
Stock super brainz is the worst carrier as he loses his shield and has no long ranged defensive options.
Camping your points has become far too effective and leads to no one attacking resulting in drawn out stalemates.
Suburbination. Look how they massacred my boy.
To start scoring a team now needs two points. This has destroyed suburbination.
I played a gw1 match recently where it was 2v3 at 63 points zombies to 21 plants. I was on plants with an agent pea as fire chomper. Despite this massive gap in both players and points the agent pea with my help was able to go from a zombie suburbination hold to plants going to suburbination at 83 zombies to 66 plants points on a 3v4 now. We were able to hold and flip the game and narrowly win at 100 to 96 when the zombies flipped back 2 points from us. It was unbelievably close and intense.
This is impossible in bfn. Due to the score now needing 2 points a winning team is just going to keep winning and the losing team can do NOTHING to turn the tide even with holding 1 point.
Vanquish confirmed. Its team vanquish but drawn out longer.
All of these also suffer the terrible spawns on bfn maps and the slower pace of 8v8 even despite sprint.
No wonder these modes had no players and were pulled. THEY WERE POORLY DESIGNED. I find more suburbination players in ps3 gw1 in 2021 than I did in bfn during its early months.
Before these maps were pulled popcap flooded lobbies with bots to combat the dying player base but even this was not enough to save mixed modes and battle arena and both were pulled due to lack of players.
The bots were also criticised for cheating at the game with their abilities and having ungodly aimbot in a game with no fall off.
Even if you like bfn you have to realize that gw1 and 2 were never at a low enough player count that they needed bots to keep the game limping on IN THEIR FIRST YEAR! This was the confirmation of the bleeding playercount in bfn as before many, especially pc players, were complaining about the lack of players.
Now I'm not against bots filling in player spots until they're taken as it allows a game to march at full speed but bfn introduced them to hide dead lobbies and with how bad yet op the bots in bfn are just leads to a bad experience.
Giddy park is not a good alternative from backyard battleground, especially for solo players. It lacks depth in its combat system against the ai and the spawns are horrendous being easy to camp. I spent most of my early gw2 time fighting the ai in the backyard or in solo play due to a lack of Xbox live and I still enjoyed it. Until solo play came to bfn this was impossible.
Part 6: The official release of bfn, several steps taken back from both garden warfares, dying game modes filled with bots and the slow death of a player base.
Why did we have no private play until near the end of the game? Gw2 had this at launch! The marketing even hyped up this feature in gw2!
We have less non turf maps than gw1!
No night maps!
This was meant to be befoore solo ops oops.
Part 7: Terrible balance and terrible animations/texture effects.
Despite having only a fraction of the characters 1&2 had bfn's balance saw little to no improvements.
We ping ponged from overpowered and buggy characters month by month starting with nightcap than after awhile we moved to all star and then superbrainz in a rough summary.
We never got fall off implemented so many characters spread was amped up and made some of them useless at longer range while others became way to effective at countersniping because they couldn't balance without fall off. Imp was destroyed by this and chomper flourishes despite being a "melee character".
All the characters moved at the same speed while sprinting so a sunflower will arrive at the objective at the same time as a citron and imp and all star are the same.
1v1s now revolved around which character you were now playing rather than the players skills factoring in as a citron in bfn will always destroy an imp with his stun roll combo and branium basher is straight up uncounterable at times if you're a 125 health plant.
The game now is dominated by station and branium basher while classes like imp and corn are pathetic.
Sunflowers damage was absolutely gutted making her combat effectiveness terrible.
The animations are also terrible in bfn.
All the returning characters abilities visual effects are much less vibrant and detailed than their gw counterpart.
Imps lights dont blink and his reload is pathetic.
Soldier doesn't bonk his head.
All stars rotors don't spin. Ps3 all stars rotors spun, wth popcap?
Soldiers shots look awful and dont even leave a paint splat. Ps3 gw1 has superior soldier effects wth.
The character models from gw are all severly less detailed besides superbrainz.
Z mech doesn't even explode. It just has a explosion filter with some screws over it.
3fps payload moving speed. The golf bomb and bootering ram didn't look this choppy.
Scientist has no visual windup for his warps and now travels instantly making his survival guaranteed with the instant heal bomb.
Superbrainz cape flows less when not moving. Hair is better though.
No idle animations for characters.
Crazy dave and Dr. Zomboss aren't even animated anymore.
Despite popular belief players do notice these details in games!
For reference:
I could sit here explaining the problems the balance had when the game was supported in greater depth but this post is long enough and I don't feel like writing a novel.
