Forum Discussion
31 Replies
I've just agreed with you on the comment you replied to. You changed my mind
Then it seems I must reiterate my point. Again.
I personally don't have a problem with trans. I was asking if the Kaminoans would. When Sim reminded me of clone individuality, I changed my mind as Sister's decision to be trans fits perfectly with the clone's desire to be not just a number. Clear?
- GRANDOLAKEV5 days agoSeasoned Hotshot
Trans = defect is all you keep saying. Saying hypothetically a fictional character may have thought what you are clearly thinking is still you saying it.
You keep saying " IMO maybe these fictional characters should be thinking it's a defect and destroy her". They are fine with clone 99, clones having individuality but on this point they should surely agree with your bigoted view.
Keep saying " I'm not paying attention" if you want, your only saying Trans =Defect over and over again but you are pretending that fictional characters with no stared preference should be saying it instead of owning it yourself.
- SimVelocity5 days agoSeasoned Veteran
But it's obvious the Kaminoans DIDN'T see her as a defect which is why she was able to serve the Army of the Grand Republic 😒
Tell me you didn’t pay attention without telling me.
I did not say being trans in general was a defect. If you’d bothered to pay attention, you would know that I was saying the Kaminoans might have considered the decision to be trans too far of a variation from their ideal vision of a clone, an opinion that I have backtracked on.
- GRANDOLAKEV5 days agoSeasoned Hotshot
Outrun is just being Anti Trans, it's not that deep. Just because you say you are not being so doesn't make it the case. You are calling being Trans a mental defect. You are being Anti Trans.
- SimVelocity5 days agoSeasoned Veteran
Actually what if she was a Clone Trooper GL? I'm not sure which other Clone Trooper could be considered except for maybe one of the Null-class Advanced Recon Commandos or even one of Delta Squad.
TBH, with the power creep that's been going she'd be able to one shot GLs
- SimVelocity5 days agoSeasoned Veteran
Great, then whether she gets added isn't a huge deal and hopefully once she is playable there'll be little discourse except for whether her abilities are broken or overpowered, not because she's trans.
I don't know why you seem to be getting aggressive. It is, in fact, related to the topic, because you said that simply because she is alive means she must not have been deemed a defect. What I'm saying is that just because the people in charge make a decision, doesn't mean I have to lap it up. Is Rey being the chosen one canon? Sure! Does it make sense? Absolutely not.
I say again, I don't have a problem with trans people in Star Wars. I'm questioning if it makes sense for the Kaminoans to have not deemed her defective. Now you've raised the point of unique personality traits, I realise it's not so different from the other clones who want unique identities and are not "just a number".
But to blindly claim I'm being transphobic, despite me explicitly stating so in previous comments, shows to me that you are not entirely paying attention to the points I have been making. I am now agreeing with you that Sister's decision to be Sister is simply another perfectly fine example of clone individuality, but it was never my intention to come across as transphobic.
About SWGOH General Discussion
Community Highlights
- CG_Meathead10 months ago
Capital Games Team
Recent Discussions
- 6 seconds ago
- 7 minutes ago
- 10 minutes ago