Raid rewards comparison with data

"CorranHorn80;c-2420517" wrote:

"Ultra;c-2420466" wrote:

"CorranHorn80;d-263330" wrote:
So I did the math on the old system vs. the new. For the record I am in a 500 million gp guild.

These numbers are per month, based on 10 Rancor, 8 Tank, 6 Sith, and 5 Cpit per month. With an average of 5th-10th place for Sith and Cpit.

New raid numbers are based on 130 million guild crate, and 4.5 million personal crate.

I undervalued the old gear boxes since finding data on those is sketchy.

Old rewards
18.7 million credits
1.4 million ship credits
35 aeromagnifiers
1836 carbanti level gear
42 kyros
And all gear in boxes (240 carbanti level and 110 fusion furnace level based on very low numbers)

New rewards
38.5 aeromagnifiers (mk3 currency)
632 fusion furnace or equivalent (mk2 currency)
3852 carbanti level gear (mk1 currency)

So the long story short, is for this situation:

Mk1 currency is slightly better rewards
Mk2 currency is about the same
Mk3 currency is about the same

But, if you make less than those crates, which a lot of guilds will, it is not a good value. Anything less than 130 million guild crate deletes the aeromagnifier level mk3 tokens.

So any guild that could do cpit, but does not get the above rewards is suffering.

Hopefully we will see a change

I really don't trust your data at all

Where are you getting 42 kyros from????????

Kyrotech is technically carbanti level gear

Lots of vagueness without any backing of your sources

Here is the full data.

10 times a month doing each currency x10

Krayt guild box level 130 million

Mk 1-42,600
Mk 2-24,750
Mk 3-6,750


Personal box level 4.5

Mk 1-42,150
Mk 2-17,600
Mk 3-1,000

So per month combined
Mk 1-84,750
Mk 2-42,350
Mk 3-7,750

That buys
1 aero is 200 Mk 3. That is 38.5 aero magnifiers. No other mk3 currency left

1 fusion furnace is 67 mk2. That is 632 fusion furnace or equivalent. That is one of the cheaper ones

1 mk3 carbanti is 22 mk1. That is 3852 carbanti or equivalent


Old raids

Rancor

10 times a month
Shards 100 Han Solo
8300 guild tokens
3 million credits
Variable gear

Tank

8 times a month
Shards 48 kenobi
11,200 guild tokens
5,760,000 credits
1,456,000 ship credits
Variable gear

Sith

6 times a month assuming 5th place
Shards 42 Traya
12,450 guild tokens
3,300 get 1 currency
3 million credits roughly
Variable gear


Cpit

5 times a month assuming 5th place
2,750 get 1 currency
2,750 get 2 currency
35 aeromagnifiers
4 million credits

Totals
Shards 190
Get 1 6,050
Get 2 2,750
Guild tokens 31,950
18.7 million credits
1.4 million ship credits
35 aero magnifiers
Lots of variable gear

That’s assuming rank 5-10 depending on the raid

What you can buy with that, that we lost

570 ship credits per mk1
So 48 million ship credits

30 shard shop per shard, so 5,700 shard shop

Guild tokens can buy 1400 carbanti
Get 1 can buy 252 carbanti
Get 2 can buy 42 kyro
Shard shop can buy 184 carbanti

So total 1836 carbanti and 42 kyro

Old rewards
18.7 million credits
1.4 million ship credits
35 aeromagnifiers
1836 carbanti level gear
42 kyros
And all gear in boxes (240 carbanti level and 110 fusion furnace level)


New rewards
38.5 aeromagnifiers (mk3 currency)
632 fusion furnace or equivalent (mk2 currency)
3852 carbanti level gear (mk1 currency)

This feels disingenuous to me

Nobody is reasonably running CPit 5x a month unless they are mercing which is an outlier

It’s better to compare one run of each raid than multiplying and per expected month

Also, 130 million is your chosen box but it would be fairer to mention what rewards you get at different boxes rather than choosing 130 million

I’m not sure how you can select rank 5-10 of other raids either

That’s also disingenuous

Sim gives you rank 11 rewards

So you should look at rank 11 rewards of the legacy raids in comparison (yes even HStr, because if they kept the old format but introduced Sim it would be rank 11)