My Sim is now acquainted with three different Grim Reapers and the first one won't come to my lot anymore. I used the Grimmaphone to summon him and I trying to max out the relationship, but after a while, it summoned a completely different Reaper. I didn't try to build a relationship with this new one, but it eventually summoned a third one. I can chat with my friend-Reaper through the Relationships panel and flirt with him through Social Bunny, but I can't invite him over anymore. Is there any way to summon the original Reaper or otherwise get him to my lot somehow? I don't use any mods at all.
@TayloShoesUnfortunately, I don't think there's any way to summon the reaper without the grimophone unless you're there when another sim dies, and even then it might just be the latest in the duplicate lineup anyway.
It sucks, but we may just have to restart with a new save and do the event over just to see what happens. It might be a "ask the grim reaper to pursue dream job" issue, but from what you're describing it might also be a relationship meter issue? As in, any progress in it breaks the reaper. But I'm not sure. I've had different grims have totally different sexualities, some seemingly panromantic while another was other completely aroace, yet I've had issues with the duplicating reaper for both of them
