Farming, Supernatural, or Tropical Vacation, Depending On Age Group?

My gameplay style has always been realistic with an edge so the supernatural elements always add into my storytelling. Tropical is nice because I love the beach but it's not needed.

Gardening is already kind of boring for me so i don't see the appeal of farming. Unless they bring back juice making. Honestly if I want a farming game, I'll play Stardew Valley.