More than one?

All the nails I found when I was looking were "rings" too. But @Bananas_45 might know of some that aren't, so paging her :)

Nothing is really possible with this game. Maybe someone will make or has made a mod for this.

Awww. Well thanks guys for the replies!Guess I'll just work with what I got.

@Bananas_45, thanks for the link! But Lana's is my go to for all things cc! It's strange because I can only have either the nails or the rings. If I pick nails first then click rings, the nails will be replaced and vice versa. Maybe I have something in my game that I haven't hunted down yet that is causing a conflict.

@SkyeChimes I'll check out XUrbansimX when I get the chance. Thanks!

When I was using mods/CC, I found some nails under gloves.

As sims tend to wear gloves less often than rings, I found it was useful.

Thank you for the shout out @luthienrising. Hello @GoldenBuffy. Ugh, my computer has crashed twice while I was trying to make a list for you. So, admitting list defeat, I will just give you the link to the nails category at Lana's CC Finds:
http://sssvitlans.tumblr.com/tagged/s4nail

There are several options to choose from. Pralinesims and Pinkzombie Cupcakes both have quite a few. Just search the pictures for hands with rings and go for it. I even checked the ones labeled ring category with my game and they worked fine with rings. There are also some in the bracelet category. Sinesims is a deleted Tumblr account.

Let me know if you need any help.

I would check XUrbansimX YouTube videos on CC shopping - I don't use CC but she does and I know that her sims basically ALWAYS have both rings and nails.

@GoldenBuffy how disappointing. I think one of Pralinsims nails is in the bracelets category. As I said, I game tested all the nails that had rings in the pictures and they worked for me. Have you specifically tried Pinkzombiecupcakes and Pralinesims nails?

@Bananas_45, just checked my nails folder and surprising I have no nails for PinkZombie or Pralinesims. I'm going to download some and test those out!

@GoldenBuffy I hope they work for you!