I found him!!!! After 431 islands
My entire villager hunt in the spoiler
Spoiler1. Tucker
2. Ava- she's a dreamie, but I don't want her on DevilFalls
3. Sydney- have on Goose Isle
4. Rex
5. Eunice
6. Merengue
7. Fauna- have on Goose Isle
8. Papi- why do I keep finding villagers I have on Goose Isle
9. Tucker
10. Derwin
11. Alice
12. Benedict
13. Lily- another dreamie, but for my other island
14. Alice
15. Dora- on sister fruit island. I just found out my sister fruit is oranges, same as what mom sent me
16. Anicotti
17. Bubbles
18. Gabi
19. Pango
20. Rodeo- want him, but not in starter house
21. Tabby
22. Bubbles- on sister fruit island
23. Kitt
24. Puck
25. Weber
26. Derwin
27. Paolo
28. Patty
29. Anicotti- sister fruit island
30. Maple
31. Wade
32. Simon
33. Rodeo
34. Pompom
35. Margie
36. Bubbles- Sister fruit island
37. Skye
38. Punchy
39. Boomer
40. June
41. Anicotti
42. Doc
43. Anabelle
44. Rhonda
45. Bianca
46. Bertha
47. Clay
48. Flurry- sister fruit island
49. Dora
50. Winnie!
51. Alfonso
52. Jacob
53. Rodeo
54. Norma- sister fruit island
55. Pudge
56. Rex
57. Sydney
58. Deena
59. Walker
60. Rhonda
61. Annalisa
62. Annalisa- again lol
63. Jacob
64. Clay
65. Al
66. Stitches
67. Dora
68. Nana
69. Flurry- Sister fruit
70. Norma
71. Nana
72. Peaches
73. Hornsby
74. Gladys
75. Beau
76. Bertha- sister fruit
77. Sandy
78. Nate- love him, had on Goose Isle
79. Celia- sister fruit
80. Ellie- have her on Goose Isle
81. Bertha- sister fruit
82. Carrie
83. Claude- sister fruit (I’ve stopped gathering the fruit tho)
84. Eunice
85. Norma
86. Nana
87. Skye
88. Egbert
89. Cranston
90. Erik
91. Stella
92. Nate
93. Zucker
94. Dizzy
95. Sally
96. Raddle
97. Chevre
98. Flurry
99. Rhonda
100. Margie
101. Molly
102. Marcie
103. Clay- sister fruit
104. Stella
105. Rex
106. Gladys
107. Benedict
108. Alice
109. Lucky- want him, but not as starter
110. Norma- sister fruit
111. Anchovy
112. Marcie
113. Cally
114. Papi
115. Alfonso- sister fruit
116. Coco
117. Skye
118. Doc
119. Al
120. Sylvana
121. Joey- sister fruit
122. Bertha
123. Elmer
124. Stitches
125. Paolo
126. Cally
127. Chevre
128. Hopkins
129. Al
130. Skye
131. Eunice
132. Al
133. Gala
134. Annalisa
135. Cranston
136. Savannah
137. Molly
138. Sylvana
139. Lolly
140. Dizzy
141. Bettina
142. Sydney
143. Cranston
144. Norma
145. Nana- sister fruit
146. Joey
147. Merengue
148. Rex
149. Spork- sister fruit
150. Lucky
151. Lucy
152. Hornsby
153. Zucker
154. Eunice
155. Molly
156. Broccolo
157. Marcie
158. Derwin
159. Drake
160. Stella
161. Rhonda
162. Olive!
163. Tucker
164. Deli
165. Pudge
166. Broccolo
167. Al
168. Rodeo
169. Hornsby
170. Nate
171. Big Top
172. Erik
173. Broccolo
174. Walker
175. Deli
176. Drago- sister fruit
177. Rex
178. Doc
179. Broccolo
180. Egbert
181. Al
182. Spork
183. Zucker
184. Rex
185. Sherb
186. Deli
187. Barold
188. Nate
189. Rex
190. Cranston- Sister fruit
191. Filbert
192. Rex
193. Alfonso
194. Cube
195. Rex
196. Jacob
197. Hornsby
198. Moe
199. Broccolo
200. Tucker
201. Spork
202. Cranston- sister fruit
203. Filbert
204. Sherb- Sister fruit
205. Hugh
206. Ozzie
207. Rex
208. Clyde
209. Sherb
210. Sherb
211. Nate
212. Deli
213. Broccolo
214. Egbert
215. Ozzie
216. Erik
217. Elmer- sister fruit
218. Sherb
219. Cube
220. Bob
221. Broccolo
222. Broccolo
223. Zucker
224. Prince- sister fruit
225. Drake
226. Nate
227. Alfonso
228. Benedict
229. Deli
230. Zucker
231. Rex
232. Broccolo
233. Filbert
234. Chester
235. Jeremiah
236. Cranston
237. Elmer
238. Paolo- sister fruit
239. Paolo
240. Doc
241. Doc
242. Erik
243. Prince
244. Raddle
245. Benjamin
246. Cranston
247. Sherb
248. Sherb
249. Filbert
250. Deli
251. Claude
252. Bones
253. Clyde
254. Elmer
255. Clay
256. Filbert
257. Spork
258. Zucker
259. Ozzie
260. Jacob
261. Sherb
262. Rodeo
263. Jeremiah
264. Drago
265. Jeremiah
266. Filbert
267. Wade
268. Alfonso
269. Ozzie
270. Zucker
271. Bob
272. Hornsby
273. Clyde
274. Rodeo
275. Hornsby
276. Drago
277. Jacob
278. Zucker
279. Ozzie
280. Jacob
281. Puck
282. Beau
283. Zucker
284. Anchovy
285. Cranston
286. Raddle
287. Erik
288. Paolo
289. Benedict
290. Jeremiah
291. Cranston
292. Paolo
293. Zucker
294. Dizzy
295. Erik
296. Paolo
297. Filbert
298. Broccolo
299. Zucker- sister fruit
300. Prince
301. Alfonso
302. Al
303. Doc- sister fruit
304. Claude
305. Jacob
306. Drake
307. Clyde- sister fruit
308. Hornsby
309. Barold
310. Benjamin
311. Barold
312. Bob
313. Nate
314. Jeremiah
315. Puck
316. Al
317. Alfonso
318. Clyde
319. Barold
320. Filbert
321. Brocollo
322. Marcel
323. Hornsby
324. Erik
325. Filbert
326. Al
327. Jacob
328. Deli
329. Al
330. Zucker
331. Simon
332. Dizzy
333. Filbert- sister fruit
334. Jeremiah
335. Simon
336. Jacob
337. Puck
338. Erik
339. Egbert
340. Weber
341. Benedict
342. Al
343. Alfonso
344. Joey
345. Egbert
346. Papi
347. Cranston
348. Beau
349. Chester
350. Hugh
351. Zucker
352. Hornsby
353. Sherb
354. Egbert
355. Chester
356. Ozzie
357. Al
358. Punchy
359. Raddle
360. Cube
361. Stu
362. Stu
363. Filbert
364. Chester
365. Cranston
366. Zucker
367. Hornsby
368. Marcel
369. Stitches
370. Clay
371. Filbert
372. Nate
373. Drago
374. Nate
375. Rodeo
376. Rodeo
377. Hornsby
378. Hugh
379. Broccolo
380. Anchovy
381. Weber
382. Clyde
383. Hopkins- sister fruit
384. Moe
385. Nate
386. Hornsby
387. Puck- sister fruit
388. Drago
389. Anchovy
390. Zucker
391. Rodeo
392. Big Top
393. Cranston- sister fruit
394. Drago
395. Hopkins
396. Filbert
397. Filbert
398. Ozzie
399. Benedict
400. Cranston
401. Ozzie
402. Al
403. Weber
404. Zucker
405. Claude
406. Elmer
407. Jacob
408. Hornsby
409. Stu
410. Drake
411. Rodeo
412. Rex
413. Rex
414. Dizzy- sister fruit
415. Jacob
416. Sherb- sister fruit
417. Drago
418. Hugh
419. Al
420. Cranston
421. Paolo
422. Al
423. Anchovy
424. Hornsby
425. Tucker
426. Simon
427. Al
428. Deli
429. Erik
430. Alfonso
431. Cole!- sister fruit