EA Forums - Banner

4 refs on the ice... not good for gameplay

Prev13
i get people want their sim puck, but 4 refs on the ice makes it a cluttered mess. they blend in with other dark helmets and add nothing to the gameplay. in fact, they take away from the gameplay, since they are always getting in the way, snaking and cutting you off all over the ice. they bunch up on the boards and make it difficult to track the puck. this needs to go.

a gamechanger told me they don't interfere with you, but that is simply not true. please take at least 3 of them out in EASHL, this is a video game afterall. if the offline players want 4 refs for realism i don't care, but at least give me the option to remove them from my screen.

Replies

  • I liked it better when you stuck to complaining about skating lol...I've never even noticed 4 refs on the ice to be completely honest, and definitely never noticed them interfering with the gameplay. Maybe we can stick to trying to get them to fix the actual game before this becomes the back of the box "#1 feature requested by the fans" for 19?
  • I liked it better when you stuck to complaining about skating lol...I've never even noticed 4 refs on the ice to be completely honest, and definitely never noticed them interfering with the gameplay. Maybe we can stick to trying to get them to fix the actual game before this becomes the back of the box "#1 feature requested by the fans" for 19?

    do you play on overhead camera? as a LW i am shock that you don't notice 2 of them sitting at the opposing blue line blocking you're zone entrance. if you happen to run into one, they hook your leg and skate with you down the ice, it's horrifying. also, as i mentioned above if you're playing a team with dark helmets they can look like defenders.

    another HUGE issue with playing on overhead is that the scoreboard is always in the way when the puck is loose in the left corner. these issues may seem minor but they do negatively affect the game.

  • I suggest lets get rid of that ugly scoreboard too than! Lol
  • I agree skid the refs . I will take fun over realism any day!
    The scoreboard should be adjustable or way smaller and out of the play. this scoreboard just shows pure neglect on EA. such an easy fix but they don't give a ****.
  • Two refs, two linesmen
  • I agree skid the refs . I will take fun over realism any day!
    The scoreboard should be adjustable or way smaller and out of the play. this scoreboard just shows pure neglect on EA. such an easy fix but they don't give a ****.

    i agree, they really don't give a hoot about anything useful it seems. lets add arcade 3s though! literally played that mode once, and it was a terrible experience with no arcade feel. the scoreboard and refs/linesmen has been an issue for 4 game cycles now.

    it really boggles my mind, that with everything wrong with this game, they spent time to program extra refs on the ice. they can't blame the suits for that one either, i highly doubt any suit told them they 'needed more refs on the ice and that it's a priority'.
  • it really boggles my mind, that with everything wrong with this game, they spent time to program extra refs on the ice. they can't blame the suits for that one either, i highly doubt any suit told them they 'needed more refs on the ice and that it's a priority'.

    This is a case where the devs were really responding to what users wanted. In the old days, there were lots of people demanding 4 officials on the ice. I don't think people really thought through what it would look like, or how it would clutter things up. They just wanted them so the game would look like real hockey. I think it was a mistake.

  • Sinbin
    1331 posts Member
    It would be good to have the option to turn them off. I use the Zone camera and they aren't that distracting, but it would still be good to be able to turn off graphics that don't effect gameplay.
  • Sinbin wrote: »
    It would be good to have the option to turn them off. I use the Zone camera and they aren't that distracting, but it would still be good to be able to turn off graphics that don't effect gameplay.

    Woah, graphic settings you can change to your liking? What a novel idea... :trollface:
  • Sinbin wrote: »
    It would be good to have the option to turn them off. I use the Zone camera and they aren't that distracting, but it would still be good to be able to turn off graphics that don't effect gameplay.

    Woah, graphic settings you can change to your liking? What a novel idea... :trollface:

    Yeah. Another novel idea is actually playing the game you spend all day commenting on.
  • I liked it better when you stuck to complaining about skating lol...I've never even noticed 4 refs on the ice to be completely honest, and definitely never noticed them interfering with the gameplay. Maybe we can stick to trying to get them to fix the actual game before this becomes the back of the box "#1 feature requested by the fans" for 19?

    do you play on overhead camera? as a LW i am shock that you don't notice 2 of them sitting at the opposing blue line blocking you're zone entrance. if you happen to run into one, they hook your leg and skate with you down the ice, it's horrifying. also, as i mentioned above if you're playing a team with dark helmets they can look like defenders.

    another HUGE issue with playing on overhead is that the scoreboard is always in the way when the puck is loose in the left corner. these issues may seem minor but they do negatively affect the game.

    I was just trying to bust your balls a bit man. I don't recall seeing them interfere with the play in any of the games ive played, but i also play on Ice Cam. I'm all for eliminating anything that clutters up the screen, I already have the scoreboard turned off completely.
  • Sinbin wrote: »
    Sinbin wrote: »
    It would be good to have the option to turn them off. I use the Zone camera and they aren't that distracting, but it would still be good to be able to turn off graphics that don't effect gameplay.

    Woah, graphic settings you can change to your liking? What a novel idea... :trollface:

    Yeah. Another novel idea is actually playing the game you spend all day commenting on.

    You buying?

    But seriously that's getting old. There's a lot of reasons I don't play it. Many of which have to do with the quality of the product and lack of attention to detail. Plus I have no desire to own any of the consoles.
  • I want Realism but I want Realism when it comes to GAME PLAY (nothing else). I don't care about Hot Dog Vendors in the stands or Mascots in the stands or 4 Officials on the ice. Those things have ZERO effect on GAME PLAY! Hot Dog Vendors don't prevent people from abusing the RS by holding it out to either side (creating that invincibility bubble), Mascots don't prevent a player from getting rocked and jumping right back to his feet, retaining possession of the puck, 4 Officials on the ice don't prevent sticks/pucks from physically passing through other objects. I could care less if we played this game in an empty Arena, as long as GAME PLAY plays damn near close to perfect
  • I like having 4 officials on the ice.
  • I think you only need one ref for things like EASHL, but I would like to keep authentic officials for online versus and offline modes. Or in offline modes, give users the option.

    Personally I have never been bothered or noticed the four officials. I certainly don't think they impact gameplay in any capacity.
    Volunteer EA Forums Senior Moderator
    Xbox Live - The Snake Esq
  • Sinbin
    1331 posts Member
    Sinbin wrote: »
    Sinbin wrote: »
    It would be good to have the option to turn them off. I use the Zone camera and they aren't that distracting, but it would still be good to be able to turn off graphics that don't effect gameplay.

    Woah, graphic settings you can change to your liking? What a novel idea... :trollface:

    Yeah. Another novel idea is actually playing the game you spend all day commenting on.

    You buying?

    But seriously that's getting old. There's a lot of reasons I don't play it. Many of which have to do with the quality of the product and lack of attention to detail. Plus I have no desire to own any of the consoles.

    You're right. It is getting old. That goes both ways. I've made my point so I'm done.

  • I'm too happy have them in the game.
    I just wish they could move, skate and think like the actual human beings. Or at least close :)
  • TonyZamboni88
    61 posts Member
    edited January 2018
    I agree the Refs always be throwing me off, and I have played hockey in real life since I was 3. For video games the extra zebras just get in the way big time. Take them out. And all other dumb **** things that inhibit the view.....why is the score clock so **** huge, when the play quickly shifts to the upper right of the screen you cant see anything!
    Post edited by EA_Roger on
  • Many many people have been along for removal of pointless refs for years. Just like everything else, instead of a solution for this very real issue we get garbage like mascots lol
  • 4 refs makes the game realistic. Anything less then that will make the game feel dull.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.