EA Forums - Banner

Connectivity issues

SturmWolfe
200 posts Member
edited February 2019
I believe there is something wrong with the change between p2p and dedi servers. As I have experienced a lot of games with very poor input lag.

I have seen others also mention the same problem. I will have a good connection but my players take literally half a second or more to respond to commands.

I play on a Xbox One X with a Samsung 28" monitor with high speed refresh rate 60/120fps and millisecond input response time. Hardwired - 300 Mbps dl / 25 Mbps ul. I have an open NAT with suggested ports forwarded. I have no packet loss and my modem/router has good levels.

Previous to the update to dedi servers. I would not experience this problem unless the p2p connection was fair/poor and/or fluctuating. I could pass and switch my players instantly.

Now, it's become almost unplayable. When I switch my player it takes half a second or more for him to start even moving. So when Im trying to defend my goalie, the other player just blows right past me and I'm ending up trying to catch up. So its like my players arent even moving as fast as they should be either. They are not receiving input commands because of this delay.

So when I'm using McDavid that supposedly has 99 overall skating ability. He skates around like he's an 85 at most.

Also, when I go to shoot the puck. I have to decide well before hand or else I lose the puck.

I really don't know how else to explain how irritating this can be for not just myself but other's as well. I would greatly appreciate some sort of feedback on this. Thanks.

[Edited post title to reflect topic]
Post edited by EA_Roger on

Replies

  • What speed is your hdmi rated? I ask because you can only get 60fps with the new ones. The older ones also limit color space as well.
    All Comments pertain to 6v6 drop in unless otherwise stated..
  • What speed is your hdmi rated? I ask because you can only get 60fps with the new ones. The older ones also limit color space as well.

    It's the same high speed hdmi the Xbox One X came with. Games on Xbox are bottle necked at 60fps, but most are still 30fps.

    This problem doesn't exist on any other games I play online. Only NHL 19.

    I live in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.. I should be connecting to the western US/Canadian servers.

    This game should have region locks as well. I know the game needs to stay competitive but people connecting from NA to Europe is just not realistic. Regardless, who ever gets the better connection usually wins based off of skill set.

    Due to these input lag instances I have been placed back in Div 2 or Div 3. When I was in solid Div 1 for quite a while.
  • I'm not sure whats up with the inconsistencies game to game. I know exactly what you're experiencing and go thru it every day also. They'll blame is on interference with your router and you're controller. the issue doesn't occur all the time but it probably has something to do with compensation from your opponents connection different to yours...
    a few times i;ve corrected it with a timeout, even AI was intoxicated. haha.
  • Yep, this is caused by the dedicated servers. Dedicated servers are slower than p2p because your packets now have to go through a middle man. First your packets are sent to the dedicated server and then they're processed and sent to your opponent. Wheras before your packets would go straight from your console to your opponents. Other games make dedicated servers feel smooth by using latency/lag compensation techniques, nhl doesn't so you experience input delay instead. It's brutal because this game isn't competitive anymore, games are often decided now by whos closest to the server/who has a lower ping. Since lower ping = less input delay. You're just gonna have to learn to live with it or quit. I definitely don't play it as much anymore cause it just isn't fun with this uneven playing field.
  • I actually seemed to have got around this problem. You'll need to open ports on your router/ modem. I went from a consistent 39 ping in game to 19 ping. Which was a major difference. It was a pain to do but seems to work.
  • I actually seemed to have got around this problem. You'll need to open ports on your router/ modem. I went from a consistent 39 ping in game to 19 ping. Which was a major difference. It was a pain to do but seems to work.

    If you read my op. You'll see I have an open NAT with port forwarding set up.
  • I found the issue. I turned off my Xbox's DVR. It runs way better now. Your game isn't working well with Xbox's UI.
  • SturmWolfe wrote: »
    I believe there is something wrong with the change between p2p and dedi servers. As I have experienced a lot of games with very poor input lag.

    I have seen others also mention the same problem. I will have a good connection but my players take literally half a second or more to respond to commands.

    I play on a Xbox One X with a Samsung 28" monitor with high speed refresh rate 60/120fps and millisecond input response time. Hardwired - 300 Mbps dl / 25 Mbps ul. I have an open NAT with suggested ports forwarded. I have no packet loss and my modem/router has good levels.

    Previous to the update to dedi servers. I would not experience this problem unless the p2p connection was fair/poor and/or fluctuating. I could pass and switch my players instantly.

    Now, it's become almost unplayable. When I switch my player it takes half a second or more for him to start even moving. So when Im trying to defend my goalie, the other player just blows right past me and I'm ending up trying to catch up. So its like my players arent even moving as fast as they should be either. They are not receiving input commands because of this delay.

    So when I'm using McDavid that supposedly has 99 overall skating ability. He skates around like he's an 85 at most.

    Also, when I go to shoot the puck. I have to decide well before hand or else I lose the puck.

    I really don't know how else to explain how irritating this can be for not just myself but other's as well. I would greatly appreciate some sort of feedback on this. Thanks.

    I have seen this too. Is this due to region-locking (Due to a high amount of North American players using GameSharks/other game hacking devices.)?
  • Lowernu82
    416 posts Member
    edited February 2019
    SturmWolfe wrote: »
    I actually seemed to have got around this problem. You'll need to open ports on your router/ modem. I went from a consistent 39 ping in game to 19 ping. Which was a major difference. It was a pain to do but seems to work.

    If you read my op. You'll see I have an open NAT with port forwarding set up.

    I went dmz, opened it right up.

    but im wondering if people are lagging out their connection when match making, once you find an opponent you resume normal connection to give you advantage. still doesnt explain why teams using a bunch of 85s, their 80 overall mcdavid toews and tarasenko, and skating circles around all your small fast players. wheres the middle finder emoji when you need it, EA
  • Massecar44
    3 posts New member
    Maybe ppl are using lag switches to cause your team to be very slow and for them to get an advantage. It's all over YouTube.
  • SturmWolfe wrote: »
    I found the issue. I turned off my Xbox's DVR. It runs way better now. Your game isn't working well with Xbox's UI.

    Only asking as I'm not at home and never actually looked for this option. But is it just an option to toggle in the settings? And what setting menu is it under?

    Thanks in advance.
  • Oupik
    88 posts Member
    This game has appartemently the worst connection from all games in history of games
  • SturmWolfe wrote: »
    I found the issue. I turned off my Xbox's DVR. It runs way better now. Your game isn't working well with Xbox's UI.

    Only asking as I'm not at home and never actually looked for this option. But is it just an option to toggle in the settings? And what setting menu is it under?

    Thanks in advance.

    Yep, just go through your xbox's system settings. Go to preferences and turn off dvr or capturing.

    If you also have any downloads, uploads, or any programs still open in the backround. Finish them, Cancel and close them before you even think of opening the game.

    To EA Sports, this UI issue still exists when I played the NHL 20 beta.

    As for people with the PS4. It might be the same for them as well. If anyone can give some insight, that would be awesome.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.