2KHS skating v.s. NHL 19 skating trailer

djneohockey · July 16, 2018 9:06PM

Hi guys,
I thought it might be interesting to see both these skating systems side by side, so I captured some footage this morning and just quickly mixed it with the NHL 19 skating trailer.

Follisimo · July 17, 2018 12:21AM

Simulator looks very smooth and hopefully 19 is similar to it.

BruinsHockey08 · July 17, 2018 3:31PM

I commented on this on Facebook but I'll copy it here also:

I posted: That [the trailer] makes you appreciate 2k that much more. I took for granted I guess how good the skating looked. I defected from 2k early in the PS3 generation but late in the PS2 generation it was the better of the two games and it had a great price point.

WainGretSki · July 17, 2018 4:30PM

That 2k video does have nice looking skating, but looks very floaty at the same time.

djneohockey · July 20, 2018 4:07PM

WainGretSki wrote: »

That 2k video does have nice looking skating, but looks very floaty at the same time.

Interesting to know you feel its a bit floaty. It might be that I overdone it (by making it too smooth) or you just don't like some of the flaws that still need to be fixed/fine tuned.

WainGretSki · July 23, 2018 5:23PM

djneohockey wrote: »

WainGretSki wrote: »

That 2k video does have nice looking skating, but looks very floaty at the same time.

Interesting to know you feel its a bit floaty. It might be that I overdone it (by making it too smooth) or you just don't like some of the flaws that still need to be fixed/fine tuned.

No, that ain't it.

What I mean is, it doesn't look or feel like the players actually have weight to them. Gives the impression they aren't touching the ice. The animations are nice and fluid, but find a way to make it seem like players are actually carrying weight with them.

djneohockey · July 26, 2018 9:43PM

Thanks for the input guys. It's really interesting to see both versions and approaches side by side, especially with EAs new attempt on skating and physicality, this year.
Here is a gameplay comparison. It is sometimes hard to see where the actual puck/play is, but hopefully, you can get a "feel" of the flow from it.

djneohockey · July 27, 2018 8:37PM

Here comes the extended collisions comparison

twoorb · August 8, 2018 5:27PM

This is the game I'll likely be playing if NHL 19 doesn't come to PC.

I normally play NHL Legacy on my PS3, but I'm all in on PC gaming and would *love* to have some hockey back on the PC!

LowJacK_604 · August 31, 2018 6:58PM

Simulator 2K hockey looks extremely promising.

djneohockey · September 1, 2018 7:15PM

Thanks.
Just be prepared that it's a lot different from what EA offers.

And there are still some pretty annoying holes in AI. But as a whole, I have more fun with it than with the EA arcade approach.

HandsomeCatf1sh · September 2, 2018 7:05AM

Complete sim! Including after game showers!!

djneohockey · September 2, 2018 8:20AM

Not complete, tuned for 10-15 minutes period.

Oslik1000 · August 6, 2019 10:20AM

Hi,
Here is a right time when my old friend DJneo must be again as our hero!

Hey Neo, EA must buy your puck physics! It must be a first if anybody from EA do want make a game from the roots.
I can see how the puck is absolutely real going under goalie body. There is no any collision bubble. It looks so fantastic. I have any tears now in my eyes

I do not understand why you are not at EA develop team now?

Cheers

Socair · August 6, 2019 12:16PM

Old tread closed; please don’t necropost.

2KHS skating v.s. NHL 19 skating trailer

Replies

Howdy, Stranger!

Quick Links