EA Forums - Banner

What are the Odds?

Yea, Buddha will only give you premium items where the Mystery Box can give you both premium & non-premium stuff.

But you can also get a Mystery Box from a Buddha.

So buyer beware

Replies

  • ozwald5
    231 posts
    edited March 2013
    Yea, Buddha will only give you premium items where the Mystery Box can give you both premium & non-premium stuff.

    But you can also get a Mystery Box from a Buddha.

    So buyer beware

    I'm specifically asking about donuts. Donuts are not premium items.
  • TALLEN77
    10 posts
    edited March 2013
    These are the mystery box odds

    <Consumable id="8" name="PrizeBox" type="Box" icon="Menu_Premium_MysteryBox" rewardText="UI_BoxReward">
    <Sell allowed="false"/>
    <Cost donuts="6"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.10983">
    <Item type="consumable" name="PrizeBox"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.20983">
    <Item type="building" name="LemonTree"/>
    <Reward money="250" donuts="0" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.30983">
    <Item type="building" name="ParkingLot"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.40983">
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.50983">
    <Item type="building" name="Tree02"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.60983">
    <Item type="building" name="LargeHedge"/>
    <Item type="building" name="LargeHedge"/>
    <Item type="building" name="LargeHedge"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.70983">
    <Item type="building" name="NewspaperDispenser"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.74983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.78983">
    <Item type="building" name="Gazebo"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.82983">
    <Item type="building" name="BushSculpture"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="500" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.86983">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.90983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialBench"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="1000" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.94983">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="10" xp="0" chance="0.96983" firstTimePrize="true">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.98983">
    <Item type="character" name="SqueakyVoiceTeen"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="30" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99983">
    <Item type="consumable" name="PlatinumPrizeBox"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="2500" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99993">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="30" xp="0" chance="0.99997">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99999">
    <Item type="building" name="SpringfieldTireyard"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="40" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="1">
    <Item type="building" name="LardLadsDonuts"/>
    </Reward>
    </Consumable>
  • TALLEN77
    10 posts
    edited March 2013
    These are the Homer Buddha odds

    <Consumable id="9" name="PlatinumPrizeBox" type="Box" icon="Menu_Premium_HomerBuddha" rewardText="UI_BoxReward_Buddha">
    <Sell allowed="false"/>
    <Cost donuts="15"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.09983">
    <Item type="consumable" name="PrizeBox"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.19983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialBench"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.29983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialPlanter"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.39983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialDumpster"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.49983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.59983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialFireShrub"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.69983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialOrangeTree"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.79983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialAppleTree"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.89983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialPlayTree"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.93983">
    <Item type="character" name="SqueakyVoiceTeen"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="30" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.97983">
    <Item type="character" name="HansMoleman"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="60" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.98983">
    <Item type="building" name="FrinksLab"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="150" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="30" xp="0" chance="0.99983">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99993">
    <Item type="building" name="SpringfieldTireyard"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="40" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99997">
    <Item type="building" name="SpringfieldSign"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="170" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99999">
    <Item type="building" name="DuffBrewery"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="190" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="1">
    <Item type="building" name="VolcanoLair"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="200" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    </Consumable>
  • TALLEN77
    10 posts
    edited March 2013
    With the Homer Buddha if you draw a premium item you already have you get the equivalent in donuts
  • KrustyBrand
    15340 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    TALLEN77 wrote:
    These are the mystery box odds

    <Consumable id="8" name="PrizeBox" type="Box" icon="Menu_Premium_MysteryBox" rewardText="UI_BoxReward">
    <Sell allowed="false"/>
    <Cost donuts="6"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.10983">
    <Item type="consumable" name="PrizeBox"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.20983">
    <Item type="building" name="LemonTree"/>
    <Reward money="250" donuts="0" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.30983">
    <Item type="building" name="ParkingLot"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.40983">
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="WoodenFence"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.50983">
    <Item type="building" name="Tree02"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.60983">
    <Item type="building" name="LargeHedge"/>
    <Item type="building" name="LargeHedge"/>
    <Item type="building" name="LargeHedge"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.70983">
    <Item type="building" name="NewspaperDispenser"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.74983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialWoodenFence"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.78983">
    <Item type="building" name="Gazebo"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.82983">
    <Item type="building" name="BushSculpture"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="500" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.86983">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.90983">
    <Item type="building" name="SpecialBench"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="1000" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.94983">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="10" xp="0" chance="0.96983" firstTimePrize="true">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.98983">
    <Item type="character" name="SqueakyVoiceTeen"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="30" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99983">
    <Item type="consumable" name="PlatinumPrizeBox"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="2500" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99993">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="30" xp="0" chance="0.99997">
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="0.99999">
    <Item type="building" name="SpringfieldTireyard"/>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="40" xp="0"/>
    </Reward>
    <Reward money="0" donuts="0" xp="0" chance="1">
    <Item type="building" name="LardLadsDonuts"/>
    </Reward>
    </Consumable>

    So how are we to interpret these numbers? They clearly mean something, but they're not odds and they're not probabilities.
  • tallen77
    62 posts
    edited March 2013
    Sorry I forgot the main part

    The chances of the items in a box are related to each other. When determining which item is picked within a box, a number between 0 and 1 is generated.
    This number is compared to the chances of the items in order, and takes the first one with a chance greater or equal to the number generated.
    If no items have a greater value, no item is obtained.
    Example:
    Items with chances: 0.2, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.65
    Value rolled: 0.46
    Compare with first: 0.2 < 0.46, fails.
    Compare with second: 0.4 < 0.46, fails
    Compare with third: 0.5 >= 0.46, passes <- this item is awarded, stop here.

    If a number greater than 0.65 was rolled, no item would be awarded.


    So I would suppose that it rolls a random 5 digit number between 0 and 1 and elects the first number that is greater or equal to as the prize. Therefore this isn't much help as you'd need the odds of rolling each number and I don't know if they are weighted or not
  • Samwellthefirst
    201 posts
    edited March 2013
    So essentially there is an equal chance of getting any of the available items?

    Edit: ^^^ as you can see I'm an idiot
  • tallen77
    62 posts
    edited March 2013
    There's probably a weighting in the rolling of the number but I didn't see it listed.
  • Samwellthefirst
    201 posts
    edited March 2013
    tallen77 wrote:
    Sorry I forgot the main part

    The chances of the items in a box are related to each other. When determining which item is picked within a box, a number between 0 and 1 is generated.
    This number is compared to the chances of the items in order, and takes the first one with a chance greater or equal to the number generated.
    If no items have a greater value, no item is obtained.
    Example:
    Items with chances: 0.2, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.65
    Value rolled: 0.46
    Compare with first: 0.2 < 0.46, fails.
    Compare with second: 0.4 < 0.46, fails
    Compare with third: 0.5 >= 0.46, passes <- this item is awarded, stop here.

    If a number greater than 0.65 was rolled, no item would be awarded.


    So I would suppose that it rolls a random 5 digit number between 0 and 1 and elects the first number that is greater or equal to as the prize. Therefore this isn't much help as you'd need the odds of rolling each number and I don't know if they are weighted or not

    The weighting comes with how close together the numbers are, toward the end of the list with all the premiums the numbers are closer together, so less chance of those items being picked

    Thus, there is a 0.001% chance of getting lard lad on a misery box :evil:
  • tallen77
    62 posts
    edited March 2013
    Thanks! I was always terrible at odds. It's why I don't bet on horse races :)
  • KrustyBrand
    15340 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    tallen77 wrote:
    Sorry I forgot the main part

    The chances of the items in a box are related to each other. When determining which item is picked within a box, a number between 0 and 1 is generated.
    This number is compared to the chances of the items in order, and takes the first one with a chance greater or equal to the number generated.
    If no items have a greater value, no item is obtained.
    Example:
    Items with chances: 0.2, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.65
    Value rolled: 0.46
    Compare with first: 0.2 < 0.46, fails.
    Compare with second: 0.4 < 0.46, fails
    Compare with third: 0.5 >= 0.46, passes <- this item is awarded, stop here.

    If a number greater than 0.65 was rolled, no item would be awarded.


    So I would suppose that it rolls a random 5 digit number between 0 and 1 and elects the first number that is greater or equal to as the prize. Therefore this isn't much help as you'd need the odds of rolling each number and I don't know if they are weighted or not

    The weighting comes with how close together the numbers are, toward the end of the list with all the premiums the numbers are closer together, so less chance of those items being picked

    Thus, there is a 0.001% chance of getting lard lad on a misery box :evil:

    Exactly. I don't know for sure, of course, but I would guess the random number generator uses a simple uniform distribution.

    Great posts by both tallen and sam.
  • ozwald5
    231 posts
    edited March 2013
    I appreciate the effort but my question has not been answered. Let me be perfectly clear:
    I want to know (assuming all premiums are already acquired) are the odds to receive donuts better when buying a Buddah or a Mystery Box?
  • KrustyBrand
    15340 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    ozwald5 wrote:
    I appreciate the effort but my question has not been answered. Let me be perfectly clear:
    I want to know (assuming all premiums are already acquired) are the odds to receive donuts better when buying a Buddah or a Mystery Box?

    Actually, if I'm not mistaken, all of the information necessary to calculate the desired odds is available in the aforementioned tables provided by tallen. Gettin' ready for bed at the moment or I'd put pencil to paper and give you an answer now.
This discussion has been closed.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.