Law & Order: Simpson's Victims Unit (Day 7 ends Thursday at 10:30 PM AWST)

Annathewicked

I feel Like - :roll: - contributes a lot sometimes.......

johnny50373

@Fmust:
"3rd party" is just the term that the GLs use for the traitor role.
Not SFer. Not villain. 3rd party.

Edit:
To expand on the above.
Traitors aren't really on any team or rather, they are SFers unless killed at night. If a traitor is killed at night, they become a villain on that team. If lynched during the day, they die normally. If the traitor isn't killed and the SFers win the game, the traitor wins as a SFer.

Some players want to be "turned" and some don't.

johnny50373

@Brandon:
You think you've seen cheating! Try playing checkers with a 5 year old! :?

brandonl1226

johnny50373 wrote:

@Brandon:
You think you've seen cheating! Try playing checkers with a 5 year old! :?

Are we talking about a an actual 5 year old or a person who acts like a 5 year old? Because I've played against the latter

ghallmark814

johnny50373 wrote:

@Brandon:
You think you've seen cheating! Try playing checkers with a 5 year old! :?

How do you know the 5 year old was cheating? They might have beat you with pure skill!

johnny50373

ghallmark814 wrote:

johnny50373 wrote:

@Brandon:
You think you've seen cheating! Try playing checkers with a 5 year old! :?

How do you know the 5 year old was cheating? They might have beat you with pure skill!

I hadn't considered that.
Now I feel like a loser.

He(my son) beat me this evening. He had 5 single checkers and one king left. He kicked my *. In my defense, his momma told him it was time for bed. He wasn't happy. I told him, he could wait and go to bed when the game was over.

I'll tell you what though, I don't like playing memory with him. He is REALLY good. I don't know if I'd go so far as to say, he has a photographic memory but I don't know, maybe. It's really frustrating because my short-term memory is... Not good.

jae_bazz

I'm so happy no one died last night!

On the issue of the silencer role, I feel like we can be fairly confident that the person with that power isn't a villain. A lot of the people silenced have been either targets of suspicion or more quiet players. That says to me that the silencer is trying to do things that help the innocent team. I feel certain that (as several have pointed out) if a villain was silencing people than Johnny would have been targeted by now. He's been our knight in shining armor this game...

The story does make it seem like there wasn't a protector role in play, maybe it is a power with the ability to deflect a night kill? I think this line from the story is the key:

The list of dead players was about half way through before the cameras focused back on the house. They zoomed inside. The figure that had been shot stood up, looked at the camera...And then the show stopped for the day.

So Lisa thought the body was dead, but then they got back up and walked away?

henpot7514

List time!!

Anna
Henpot
Yukon
Jae
Johnny
Blue
Ghall
Mary
Wilki
Smohqy
Fmust

Here's who's left. 2 out of 11 of this list are villains.

Yukon and Smohqy cannot be the silencer since they have been silenced.
I believe Johnny to be innocent. I am innocent.

So that leads me to believe there are two villains from these;
Blue / Ghall / Anna / Mary / Jae / Yukon / Fmust / Smohqy / Wilki

henpot7514

ghallmark814 wrote:

--Smoq

As stated, mine was a wake up vote.

He is still pretty high on my list. Hey Jae, if your out there, make it easy for me.. What was the reasoning behind a YG vote?

I've been tapping rather than reading.

My "list" is at 4 High, 2 medium.. the rest low right now.

@smoq, Johnny *is*working hard, but I give him credit for transparency. He has explained his thought process pretty well and even said things that looked bad for himself.. If Johnny is a villain Hats off to him.. He's playing a hella game.

Going to go read up before the vote.

Hey Ghall, can you explain what you mean here please?

johnny50373

jae_bazz wrote:

I'm so happy no one died last night!

On the issue of the silencer role, I feel like we can be fairly confident that the person with that power isn't a villain. A lot of the people silenced have been either targets of suspicion or more quiet players. That says to me that the silencer is trying to do things that help the innocent team. I feel certain that (as several have pointed out) if a villain was silencing people than Johnny would have been targeted by now. He's been our knight in shining armor this game...

The story does make it seem like there wasn't a protector role in play, maybe it is a power with the ability to deflect a night kill? I think this line from the story is the key:

The list of dead players was about half way through before the cameras focused back on the house. They zoomed inside. The figure that had been shot stood up, looked at the camera...And then the show stopped for the day.

So Lisa thought the body was dead, but then they got back up and walked away?

Yeah, that's what I was thinking. Usually, the protector is mentioned.
I think a "known" innocent was almost certainly targeted. Probably, someone with no suspicion against them.
The villains will need anyone with any suspicion against them at all to stick around. The villains will have to give other options if they start to get votes.

jae_bazz

johnny50373 wrote:

jae_bazz wrote:

I'm so happy no one died last night!

On the issue of the silencer role, I feel like we can be fairly confident that the person with that power isn't a villain. A lot of the people silenced have been either targets of suspicion or more quiet players. That says to me that the silencer is trying to do things that help the innocent team. I feel certain that (as several have pointed out) if a villain was silencing people than Johnny would have been targeted by now. He's been our knight in shining armor this game...

The story does make it seem like there wasn't a protector role in play, maybe it is a power with the ability to deflect a night kill? I think this line from the story is the key:

The list of dead players was about half way through before the cameras focused back on the house. They zoomed inside. The figure that had been shot stood up, looked at the camera...And then the show stopped for the day.

So Lisa thought the body was dead, but then they got back up and walked away?

Yeah, that's what I was thinking. Usually, the protector is mentioned.
I think a "known" innocent was almost certainly targeted. Probably, someone with no suspicion against them.
The villains will need anyone with any suspicion against them at all to stick around. The villains will have to give other options if they start to get votes.

It was night 5. Is there a possibility that the villains targeted based on a suspicion of the other team?

fmust68

jae_bazz wrote:

johnny50373 wrote:

jae_bazz wrote:

I'm so happy no one died last night!

On the issue of the silencer role, I feel like we can be fairly confident that the person with that power isn't a villain. A lot of the people silenced have been either targets of suspicion or more quiet players. That says to me that the silencer is trying to do things that help the innocent team. I feel certain that (as several have pointed out) if a villain was silencing people than Johnny would have been targeted by now. He's been our knight in shining armor this game...

The story does make it seem like there wasn't a protector role in play, maybe it is a power with the ability to deflect a night kill? I think this line from the story is the key:

The list of dead players was about half way through before the cameras focused back on the house. They zoomed inside. The figure that had been shot stood up, looked at the camera...And then the show stopped for the day.

So Lisa thought the body was dead, but then they got back up and walked away?

Yeah, that's what I was thinking. Usually, the protector is mentioned.
I think a "known" innocent was almost certainly targeted. Probably, someone with no suspicion against them.
The villains will need anyone with any suspicion against them at all to stick around. The villains will have to give other options if they start to get votes.

It was night 5. Is there a possibility that the villains targeted based on a suspicion of the other team?

What do you mean? That one team went after the other? (SOrry, I'm a little groggy right now :P )

jae_bazz

fmust68 wrote:

What do you mean? That one team went after the other? (SOrry, I'm a little groggy right now :P )

Yeah, that's what I meant. That it was possible that the Marge/Lisa villain team targeted someone they suspected of being Bart.

fmust68

I'm just going to throw some stuff out there, see if anything makes sense.

What do we know? Both Lisa and Bart lost their partner.

There's always a possibility that there's a traitor in the game so maybe they're both trying to find that player. We took out the traitor. Now what? Who would Lisa go after? An innocent or Bart?

We found the first 2 villains during the day. What if a villain is targeted at night, they can't die? OR
Now that each team is down to 1, they have the ability to "find" each other and team up? :?

That may explain why there's no protector mentioned. (Is a protector always mentioned or has been in past games?)

Is there a possibility that there's another traitor?

fmust68

jae_bazz wrote:

fmust68 wrote:

What do you mean? That one team went after the other? (SOrry, I'm a little groggy right now :P )

Yeah, that's what I meant. That it was possible that the Marge/Lisa villain team targeted someone they suspected of being Bart.

Yay, my brain still works lol

jae_bazz

fmust68 wrote:

I'm just going to throw some stuff out there, see if anything makes sense.

What do we know? Both Lisa and Bart lost their partner.

There's always a possibility that there's a traitor in the game so maybe they're both trying to find that player. We took out the traitor. Now what? Who would Lisa go after? An innocent or Bart?

We found the first 2 villains during the day. What if a villain is targeted at night, they can't die? OR
Now that each team is down to 1, they have the ability to "find" each other and team up? :?

That may explain why there's no protector mentioned. (Is a protector always mentioned or has been in past games?)

Is there a possibility that there's another traitor?

Villains can die in the night if they are targeted by another team. Bart & Lisa won't be teaming up, their win objectives each require that the other is dead.

johnny50373

jae_bazz wrote:

fmust68 wrote:

I'm just going to throw some stuff out there, see if anything makes sense.

What do we know? Both Lisa and Bart lost their partner.

There's always a possibility that there's a traitor in the game so maybe they're both trying to find that player. We took out the traitor. Now what? Who would Lisa go after? An innocent or Bart?

We found the first 2 villains during the day. What if a villain is targeted at night, they can't die? OR
Now that each team is down to 1, they have the ability to "find" each other and team up? :?

That may explain why there's no protector mentioned. (Is a protector always mentioned or has been in past games?)

Is there a possibility that there's another traitor?

Villains can die in the night if they are targeted by another team. Bart & Lisa won't be teaming up, their win objectives each require that the other is dead.

I sure hope there isn't another traitor. That could be a problem. I think we're safe. Grampa is dead and I can't imagine anyone else as the traitor. I hope I'm right about this.
I think if they had teamed up, they would have killed together last night...

ghallmark814

henpot7514 wrote:

ghallmark814 wrote:

--Smoq

As stated, mine was a wake up vote.

He is still pretty high on my list. Hey Jae, if your out there, make it easy for me.. What was the reasoning behind a YG vote?

I've been tapping rather than reading.

My "list" is at 4 High, 2 medium.. the rest low right now.

@smoq, Johnny *is*working hard, but I give him credit for transparency. He has explained his thought process pretty well and even said things that looked bad for himself.. If Johnny is a villain Hats off to him.. He's playing a hella game.

Going to go read up before the vote.

Hey Ghall, can you explain what you mean here please?

Yep.. My "List" was at four people high probable villains two were medium Probable the rest are low probables.

Jblue8298

I still am curious what the secret specialty is

We don't know, right? Or did I miss something

brandonl1226

Jblue8298 wrote:

I still am curious what the secret specialty is

We don't know, right? Or did I miss something