Just to be clear, I'm voting for smoqhy because he is the most likely villain.
Johnny is a hunch, smoqhy is based more on behaviour.
I'm also interested to test johnnys theory. He was certain that Yukon and smoqhy were the villains but he's already got one wrong. Could be a ploy to hide himself. My focus is smoqhy today, if he dies then my focus returns to Johnny
Is the main evidence about Smoqhy that he asked a question about how villain roles work, or is there something else? Because I actually feel like he did a pretty good job of explaining why he asked that question...
Is the main evidence about Smoqhy that he asked a question about how villain roles work, or is there something else? Because I actually feel like he did a pretty good job of explaining why he asked that question...
I had a night job last night and I'm beat. I don't have my notes but I think the most suspicious thing was his vote for Crosby. It will be a while before I post much more. I'm going to bed.
If you look through my posts you'll see why I came to the Smohqy conclusion. Not saying, you'll agree but that's what I think.
Sorry, everyone. I've been up for 30+ hours.
Something else to think about.
At the beginning of the message has Rex and Bart are going back and forth.
MC and Fmust were going back and forth.
It also says we're getting close to Bart. Something like that. According to my list, Fmust would be the only person on the Lisa list. Maybe I was wrong about the villain/player. I need to check about Fmust. Why I thought he shouldn't be Bart.
I still think Smohqy is the one but I can't remember why.
< runs off to reread messages for the seventy eleventh Time>
Let us know if you find anything good. I'm like 2/4,685 for actually finding clues in CG messages... :P
It's a long shot.. They seem so obvious when the game is done. :?
During the game tho... Not so obvious.
It's so true. When I was GL, I was banging my damn head on the wall because I couldn't figure out how people were missing such obvious clues. But I'm not one to talk, because I never see them either....
Ok, Johnny. I read back through your posts, and I've gotta say, I'm not necessarily sold on the argument that Smoqhy is a villain. I can't guarantee that he's innocent, but I'm not super convinced either. At this point, I'm not going to be voting for him, since he's leading with the majority of votes anyhow. Even if he is guilty, there is at least one more person out there who needs their feathers ruffled. :P
I will say, I have seen you go back and forth on Wilki a lot. Now, I know the two of you can't be partners, because there's no intact villain team left, but if that wasn't the case I would be extra suspicious right now.
For now I'm placing my money on Anna. I don't feel like I can clear her as either Bart or Lisa, and I haven't found her defense of herself particularly convincing. As always, I reserve the right to change my mind if a theory I like better comes along, or if she sells me on her innocence.
The first thing that came to my mind when the evening msg was posted was that Homer & Bart were just walking by when the police were trying to look for Lisa.
MC posted then Crosby posted 3 mins later; Crosby posted then fmust posted 1 min later.
Do you think there is a chance MC or fmust could be Crosby's partner?
I'm sorry this makes no sense but I'm trying to find the words to describe what I mean and I'm not doing a very good job.
Why would homer and Bart just be walking by together all of sudden? :?
I haven't read the rest of the thread so I'm sorry if this has been covered/asked
Hen, I'm not sure what part you are referring to here. I was the second vote for Crosby, when it looked like others were voting for Wilki. If I were Crosby's partner, I wouldn't have voted for him second, after Johnny.
Not sure about Fmust.
Sorry MC! I hadn't read the thread when I posted this and never went back to edit it!
Replies
A good strategy. Why would you silence the most helpful players?
Johnny is a hunch, smoqhy is based more on behaviour.
I'm also interested to test johnnys theory. He was certain that Yukon and smoqhy were the villains but he's already got one wrong. Could be a ploy to hide himself. My focus is smoqhy today, if he dies then my focus returns to Johnny
I voted him the other day, I still feel this is the right track.
Votes:
1. Smohqy 3 votes (Wilki, Johnny, Anna)
Currently Smohqy will be lynched by receiving the most votes.
Forced vote:
Anna, Jae, Fmust.
Absent:
Nobody
I had a night job last night and I'm beat. I don't have my notes but I think the most suspicious thing was his vote for Crosby. It will be a while before I post much more. I'm going to bed.
If you look through my posts you'll see why I came to the Smohqy conclusion. Not saying, you'll agree but that's what I think.
Sorry, everyone. I've been up for 30+ hours.
Something else to think about.
At the beginning of the message has Rex and Bart are going back and forth.
MC and Fmust were going back and forth.
It also says we're getting close to Bart. Something like that. According to my list, Fmust would be the only person on the Lisa list. Maybe I was wrong about the villain/player. I need to check about Fmust. Why I thought he shouldn't be Bart.
I still think Smohqy is the one but I can't remember why.
I'll sleep and be back. :thumbup:
I did not catch that. :?
< runs off to reread messages for the seventy eleventh Time>
It's a long shot.. They seem so obvious when the game is done. :?
During the game tho... Not so obvious.
I will say, I have seen you go back and forth on Wilki a lot. Now, I know the two of you can't be partners, because there's no intact villain team left, but if that wasn't the case I would be extra suspicious right now.
For now I'm placing my money on Anna. I don't feel like I can clear her as either Bart or Lisa, and I haven't found her defense of herself particularly convincing. As always, I reserve the right to change my mind if a theory I like better comes along, or if she sells me on her innocence.
++Annathewicked