I didn't get the dialogue box. Let me see if I got the donuts.
Did you get the cauldron from the Halloween mystery box?
Yes
Do you already have Witch Marge?
Yes to both. They better not steal my cauldron away from me. I know I overpaid, but they aren't offering it otherwise. I'll have to double check that it's still there in a bit.
From what I'm seeing, this is what I think (for what it's worth):
If you had Witch Marge, and you got a cauldron from the Mystery Box, then you will receive nothing. If you didn't have Witch Marge and got a cauldron from the Mystery Box and did not receive Witch Marge, then you get 50 donuts back. Whether you get to keep said cauldron, I'm not sure. Probably you will. As for whether you'll get Witch Marge, I'm not sure.
That's my guess. Feel free to correct me.
What part of "unsolicited friend requests are all denied" do you NOT get?
TBH I don't care personally. But that said I do care for newer players. I have Marge and the caldron in 5? Towns. So I don't mind only having the caldron in one town even if it was a bit pricy.
Volunteer EA Forum Senior Moderator/Hero EA Answers HQ
Returning our 50 donuts is a nice gesture but wouldn't it of just been as easy to reward us the Witch Marge skin?? I got the download but no message of said 50 donuts..... I'm sure they'll do another patch
Replies
Do you already have Witch Marge?
No, not in this town.
Edit: cauldron is still there...for now.
If you had Witch Marge, and you got a cauldron from the Mystery Box, then you will receive nothing. If you didn't have Witch Marge and got a cauldron from the Mystery Box and did not receive Witch Marge, then you get 50 donuts back. Whether you get to keep said cauldron, I'm not sure. Probably you will. As for whether you'll get Witch Marge, I'm not sure.
That's my guess. Feel free to correct me.