EA Forums - Banner

Jarci's Springfield Grades

Replies

  • jarci1
    89 posts
    edited March 2013
    Just want to say Jarci1, your own Springfield is really starting to look great. Definitely at least a B.

    Heh...Thanks!

    Unfortunately, my remake was a little too ambitious and it looks like it could take months to complete. I still like the concept but the execution part takes hours. Clearly a D but if the mess makes you angry then it would be downgraded to an F. I'm hopeful though...one day.

    I will try to post some new grades in the next couple of days.
  • vinnylo26
    73 posts
    edited March 2013
    grade me...A++ please

    vinswizzle
  • rdee22
    77 posts
    edited March 2013
    Sent a friend request add rdee22
  • WILL-P-1998
    205 posts
    edited March 2013
    jarci1 wrote:
    Updated 2013-03-09 (added 30 people)
    Updated 2013-03-03 (added 25 people)
    Updated 2013-03-01 (added 35 people)
    Updated 2013-02-26 (added 40 people)

    Our judges have deliberated and provided up-to-date grades of various top Springfields in the community. If you would like to see how you stack up against the world's best just add jarci1 in-game.

    As you know, this is only at a point in time so if you want your city to be re-evaluated then re-add jarci1.

    Name Grade
    archimedes87 A
    bennyticklez A
    ewaldklement A
    ICE_GRYLLZ A
    jaffaface A
    Keys1980 A
    kymie1988 A
    lsleong A
    otte63 A
    Tara A
    zachvsyou A
    bluehill1 A-
    corkhopper A-
    gobeerbuy A-
    isaiahbowers A-
    missyolga A-
    petergeenen A-
    rrss0006 A-
    Simpsons00001 A-
    acheeanthony B+
    am4692 B+
    animalia6957 B+
    bluestem2722 B+
    Damebi B+
    davesmurano B+
    Doh_Inc B+
    DroppinDeuce B+
    FBMbmx12 B+
    gcoleman4 B+
    Herm412 B+
    jbondra B+
    lindylovin B+
    NeoSEC28 B+
    Other Springfield B+
    RockALittl3 B+
    Rynan1981 B+
    sherryt07 B+
    USDPC B+
    arnoutVI B
    Cujo038 B
    DiscoVonDoom B
    jesselynnste B
    Lecomx B
    marvthemonk B
    mcrizz B
    NufcNeilo B
    petencody B
    samanathon B
    steveorion B
    tadat73 B
    Wotel1963 B
    ilovetrish B-
    jacob0303 B-
    janscarol B-
    juliespencer14 B-
    Karmakhazi B-
    lotus213gdj B-
    mdales32 B-
    PasswordSuck B-
    phillip_ngo_ B-
    stageshoot B-
    Starbuxs B-
    teegy93 B-
    zljboz B-
    ambernquinn C+
    arthellman C+
    bendermac C+
    cobriendubs C+
    crother C+
    dansminiritzmad C+
    donoli81 C+
    gocatters C+
    gustavo82011 C+
    hidenburgh C+
    homershmomer C+
    Insomniaeh C+
    jamiearcher C+
    laura_jean_w C+
    lewisbyrom C+
    lynpenny327 C+
    McReady83 C+
    minionmel C+
    mosquitocat C+
    MTNRufus C+
    northstar107 C+
    rollo1986 C+
    Rsommons C+
    rubymccoachx C+
    sammercer12 C+
    scr33ch08 C+
    tombhamilton C+
    trevornslane C+
    Urmas-1 C+
    XBL-Heretic C+
    big_convoy28 C
    Bloodlaus C
    bneboy86 C
    boisecmac C
    cmartino440 C
    Danushan707 C
    dougsbeard C
    edkunsch C
    Ericdurham6969 C
    HaloBoy678 C
    iainh124a C
    janeq1 C
    jvidal1986 C
    kennedy C
    LazyUmberto C
    Legomanjn C
    mattmanX2 C
    McReady83 C
    meleagris4 C
    mischa37 C
    msteggy C
    NewsScott C
    ngopy001 C
    nossidda C
    OrganikKOTD C
    Ronin823 C
    ryu9t8 C
    toddyfunk C
    twilko-japan C
    Vandillo C
    Vileinist C
    violetdawn20 C
    adnan-turk-e17 C-
    arturo_soldatini C-
    golkokonus C-
    jayjayeire C-
    kinglala26 C-
    LastLusitanian C-
    lilydalelah C-
    macrosbellet C-
    martimunicoy C-
    mes1492 C-
    michellegazz C-
    nation8456 C-
    parker2469 C-
    plicknutz C-
    ponnejesse C-
    ReismanM C-
    robertthomps591 C-
    Sean7272 C-
    seanthesheep639 C-
    shelbypeek C-
    slamtrdmrk C-
    sliick_nikkuh C-
    Sturner37 C-
    sweaver383 C-
    thedrizzle914 C-
    Tiff729 C-
    Tony68k C-
    Troegenators C-
    usenjones C-
    XxNicksterxX C-
    Aldtai D+
    BlankVerse99 D+
    bored1089 D+
    caroudabush D+
    Dantheman2080 D+
    gazzajay D+
    GWMatMILO D+
    heartherris D+
    InspctHerGajet D+
    JasonBlythe22 D+
    JumbacoMan D+
    kcartagena85 D+
    kermit35000 D+
    kylematthew0 D+
    Lmusic4L D+
    mhsalt D+
    mhuff1109 D+
    reece_rios D+
    RHutch187129 D+
    summersun96 D+
    timprov D+
    tyto11 D+
    W1NGY71 D+
    bizbop2000 D
    BKHCBIGANT D
    camhd D
    chrischen377 D
    djcotleanu D
    GeraldL44 D
    jackm75 D
    jamesahsmith D
    jdsuker D
    jstorr D
    kindofsimple D
    krazykatie2 D
    landyacht67 D
    nickmarsh1 D
    Pinguama D
    SchoLuc D
    sdavidson94 D
    will-perks D
    xixJETxix D
    bethlees592 D-
    cgeorgepdl D-
    dfrancesca D-
    dmahoney105 D-
    dragon78sm D-
    dragonfreak113 D-
    jimpintabone D-
    kevinvl94661 D-
    krustystoner D-
    Newman25 D-
    sian555 D-
    sierra_echo692 D-
    smmi D-
    Trixistropp D-
    yummygirl22 D-
    zehnerjo719 D-
    bethlees592 F
    buddylewis77 F
    davidjstewar F
    donotcopy123 F
    Gfunk602 F
    Ihatenick182 F
    kalef1 F
    leanonsheena F
    Meconsc F
    michaeldavis561 F
    miss_shanny F
    Msjazzeee F
    nez86 F
    nilssandra F
    paulmackie10 F
    payam00 F
    rperus F
    rs876 F
    ryanward87 F
    saralandolt F
    sebizzaro F
    Siplin1982 F
    speedfreak2104x F
    stacecohen F
    stephaniemeadors F
    thatsmrwonka F
    zentaurix F

    What a disgrace! I got a D (I'm will-perks)

    It's only cos I haven't finished town and have a few buildings on top of each other in corner. Surely u wouldn't mark that.....
  • jarci1
    89 posts
    edited March 2013
    It's only cos I haven't finished town and have a few buildings on top of each other in corner. Surely u wouldn't mark that.....

    The only thing that I can 'grade' is what you 'turn in'.

    I added 20 more people and here are some comments (but rdee22 stole the show!):
    rdee22 - Love the fountain island! Love Burns manor! Real artistic talent…I would love to see a total ground-up redesign from you.
    chrisp530 - So close to A…just a couple areas need work. Did you just win the lottery? :P
    alexjonesxo - Tough one to judge. Good for limited space.
    SantPol321 - Coming along quite nicely!
    weesavvy03 - Some interesting stuff but it looks rushed overall.
  • chrisp530
    2611 posts
    edited March 2013
    Thanks!
    Still a work in progress, waiting for the next update, I know I'm going to have to move some things around.
    Lol, no lottery, just a birthday and a lot of iTunes gift cards, 4800 donuts sure buys a lot when you already have most of the premiums :)
  • lilydalelah
    134 posts
    edited March 2013
    gee, I'd love to hear some suggestions of how mine qualifies for a C- :lol: and what I might do to improve my apparent disaster of a town.

    btw glad you weren't one of my professors in school or I'd have been real stressed 8)
  • lilydalelah
    134 posts
    edited March 2013
    gee, I'd love to hear some suggestions of how mine qualifies for a C- :lol: and what I might do to improve my apparent disaster of a town.

    btw glad you weren't one of my professors in school or I'd have been real stressed 8)

    seriously, I'm open to suggestions. :)
    That wasn't meant to sound sarcastic despite it did when i read back afterwards.

    I am quite honestly getting bored lately w/ L26 and nowhere to go from there other than adding the useless multimillion (ugly) additional items. i need to do something with Burns' Manor which is shoved where i had space at rhe time, but beyond that, ideas pls??
  • gocatters
    89 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?
  • lissarv68
    5588 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    gocatters wrote:
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?

    I really don't understand this. What am I missing? I'm not being snarky or whatever but....the person has a horrible town. They've admitted they have one. Yet people are lining up to be judged by somebody who has at best a D+ town.

    Why?

    I would think you'd be asking somebody with an amazing town to give you advice on how to improve. Wouldn't their advice carry more weight and validity?
  • gocatters
    89 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    lissarv68 wrote:
    gocatters wrote:
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?

    I really don't understand this. What am I missing? I'm not being snarky or whatever but....the person has a horrible town. They've admitted they have one. Yet people are lining up to be judged by somebody who has at best a D+ town.

    Why?

    I would think you'd be asking somebody with an amazing town to give you advice on how to improve. Wouldn't their advice carry more weight and validity?

    I'm just caught up in the fun of it all I think
  • NeoSEC28
    39616 posts
    edited March 2013
    What shocks me is this thread is still going strong! :lol:
    Volunteer EA Senior Moderator
  • lissarv68
    5588 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    gocatters wrote:
    lissarv68 wrote:
    gocatters wrote:
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?

    I really don't understand this. What am I missing? I'm not being snarky or whatever but....the person has a horrible town. They've admitted they have one. Yet people are lining up to be judged by somebody who has at best a D+ town.

    Why?

    I would think you'd be asking somebody with an amazing town to give you advice on how to improve. Wouldn't their advice carry more weight and validity?

    I'm just caught up in the fun of it all I think

    That's cool. I really wasn't trying to be mean, I'm just confused and trying to understand why the need for a grade and by somebody who really isn't qualified to be giving these grades.

    Then again, those with amazing towns aren't lining up to grade or give advice either. So maybe it's just that?
  • zoephoto
    447 posts
    edited March 2013
    lissarv68 wrote:
    gocatters wrote:
    lissarv68 wrote:
    gocatters wrote:
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?

    I really don't understand this. What am I missing? I'm not being snarky or whatever but....the person has a horrible town. They've admitted they have one. Yet people are lining up to be judged by somebody who has at best a D+ town.

    Why?

    I would think you'd be asking somebody with an amazing town to give you advice on how to improve. Wouldn't their advice carry more weight and validity?

    I'm just caught up in the fun of it all I think

    That's cool. I really wasn't trying to be mean, I'm just confused and trying to understand why the need for a grade and by somebody who really isn't qualified to be giving these grades.

    Then again, those with amazing towns aren't lining up to grade or give advice either. So maybe it's just that?

    I think she's just a good salesman
    jarci1 wrote:
    Our judges have deliberated and provided up-to-date grades of various top Springfields in the community. If you would like to see how you stack up against the world's best just add jarci1 in-game

    :shock: :lol::lol::lol:

  • psukegreen
    539 posts
    edited March 2013
    lissarv68 wrote:
    gocatters wrote:
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?

    I really don't understand this. What am I missing? I'm not being snarky or whatever but....the person has a horrible town. They've admitted they have one. Yet people are lining up to be judged by somebody who has at best a D+ town.

    Why?

    I would think you'd be asking somebody with an amazing town to give you advice on how to improve. Wouldn't their advice carry more weight and validity?

    But who actually has a great town. Everyone does there town on what they like.
  • chindogger
    179 posts
    edited March 2013
    Thank for grading my city. B- :)
  • edited March 2013
    Part of me is interested in others opinions of my town and part of me is scared to know. :oops:
  • lissarv68
    5588 posts Member
    edited March 2013
    psukegreen wrote:
    lissarv68 wrote:
    gocatters wrote:
    I've made some changes as per your advice - can I be re-graded?

    I really don't understand this. What am I missing? I'm not being snarky or whatever but....the person has a horrible town. They've admitted they have one. Yet people are lining up to be judged by somebody who has at best a D+ town.

    Why?

    I would think you'd be asking somebody with an amazing town to give you advice on how to improve. Wouldn't their advice carry more weight and validity?

    But who actually has a great town. Everyone does there town on what they like.

    Well why not just post a screen shot and then ask the forum to rate it? It seems more "fair" and unbiased. It also ensures that only those who are asking to be graded are graded. She included people who just posted screenshots of their towns. They never asked to be included in some arbitrary grading system. They should be removed from that list.

    That has always been my contention point with this whole thing.

    Also, if you post "my town is not all that great" (paraphrased) and then you post grades of the towns that belong to others? Then you are setting yourself up for ridicule and hostility (especially from those who did not ask to be graded because they could care less).

    As I said, I don't care if people are lining up for these grades. I don't understand it but I don't care. I do care that some of my "friends" are on that list and they never asked to be put on it.
  • rdee22
    77 posts
    edited March 2013
    Thanks for the A- and the compliments. As for doing a full redesign that scares me. Gotta see what new buildings come out and where I can fit then in with a mini redesign
  • jarci1
    89 posts
    edited March 2013
    Lilydaleah - I don't see you on my list anymore so I can't provide comments. If you re-add me, I will add comments. Remember that I am grading against others so potentially you are against people who play TSTO all-day everyday.

    Lissarv - Now you are just being unfair...
    1. More than one person is looking at the town
    2. My town has sections that are way above average and you can clearly see that...the only reason I would give myself a bad grade is because I am in the middle of a massive redesign
    3. Even if I am the worst player ever, that still doesn't apply at all to my judging ability
    4. I am the most qualified judge in the world at this point because me and my friends and family are the only ones doing it (to my knowledge) and we have seen over 500 towns
    5. People love competition and love to see how they scale up against others. Fact.
    6. Sooner or later you are going to ask me how you stack up against everyone else (but until then I won't post even though I secretly evaluated your town :)
    7. I have removed anyone who asked me to remove them
    8. I am going to assume you are just purposely bumping my thread because you secretly like the idea
    9. 15 more people added me
    10. We will grade them tomorrow or on the weekend
    11. Typing this much on iPad was hard work so you should feel touched
This discussion has been closed.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!