I'm going to guess the two lovers conspired to vote for the same person?
Perhaps the four villains did the same? (This is a reach)
Well only 2 of them will know each other, but that's a good theory! :thumbup: that to me suggests lynn, jae and nilmade (2 of the 3) or me and proaluu (and I'm not a villain and I don't think proaluu is after they made a massive list last night).
It doesn't necessarily mean that's the case of course, but going off the 3 people who voted for the same person, I'm fairly sure Jae is innocent so that leaves Lynn and Nilmade...
I agree, two out of three from lynn, jae & nilmade could be possible villains
Would 1 stonecutter/alien vote for their stonecutter/alien counterpart to throw us off?
For instance say me and you are stonecutters Juliet, we could conspire to vote each other (as long as it wasn't damaging) to make it look like we are not part of a two
Does that make sense?
Yes. Juliet voted for me, proallu did the same and then Juliet changed her vote and voted for proallu, but seems that the GL didn't see that.
I have a headache after reading everything and I think I have to read the rules again because I'm completely lost :oops:
I did that because I was only voting for you because you had no votes, when someone else voted for you I quickly withdrew it and voted for someone else with no votes!
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
Annette was likewise skipped because the villains believe she is innocent
As well as Juliet, and proallu.
And if Wilki is telling truth then they skipped him as well.
Leaving whoever else is left in their eyes as a good group to pick from. If they didn't get a villain then oh well they at least narrowed their list down. And I believe it was just our bad luck they picked the lover which what juliet said kills both.
I've just been going through the jblues posts, I've only gone up to page 20, Not sure if she voted for wijsheld later on but there are a few posts where she suspects him. Couls he have felt threatened by the remarks made?
I'm going to guess the two lovers conspired to vote for the same person?
Perhaps the four villains did the same? (This is a reach)
Well only 2 of them will know each other, but that's a good theory! :thumbup: that to me suggests lynn, jae and nilmade (2 of the 3) or me and proaluu (and I'm not a villain and I don't think proaluu is after they made a massive list last night).
It doesn't necessarily mean that's the case of course, but going off the 3 people who voted for the same person, I'm fairly sure Jae is innocent so that leaves Lynn and Nilmade...
I agree, two out of three from lynn, jae & nilmade could be possible villains
Would 1 stonecutter/alien vote for their stonecutter/alien counterpart to throw us off?
For instance say me and you are stonecutters Juliet, we could conspire to vote each other (as long as it wasn't damaging) to make it look like we are not part of a two
Does that make sense?
Yes. Juliet voted for me, proallu did the same and then Juliet changed her vote and voted for proallu, but seems that the GL didn't see that.
I have a headache after reading everything and I think I have to read the rules again because I'm completely lost :oops:
I did that because I was only voting for you because you had no votes, when someone else voted for you I quickly withdrew it and voted for someone else with no votes!
I was just an example, I wasn't asking you for explanations :-)
The only reason I can imagine to kill jblue is that the villains knew that she was a lover (so they kill two people with one shot) but that's impossible, isn't it?
There are a few things that I don't understand. Does the GL participate in the game? I thought that he only sends the roles and counts the votes.
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
I'm going to guess the two lovers conspired to vote for the same person?
Perhaps the four villains did the same? (This is a reach)
Well only 2 of them will know each other, but that's a good theory! :thumbup: that to me suggests lynn, jae and nilmade (2 of the 3) or me and proaluu (and I'm not a villain and I don't think proaluu is after they made a massive list last night).
It doesn't necessarily mean that's the case of course, but going off the 3 people who voted for the same person, I'm fairly sure Jae is innocent so that leaves Lynn and Nilmade...
I agree, two out of three from lynn, jae & nilmade could be possible villains
Would 1 stonecutter/alien vote for their stonecutter/alien counterpart to throw us off?
For instance say me and you are stonecutters Juliet, we could conspire to vote each other (as long as it wasn't damaging) to make it look like we are not part of a two
Does that make sense?
Yes. Juliet voted for me, proallu did the same and then Juliet changed her vote and voted for proallu, but seems that the GL didn't see that.
I have a headache after reading everything and I think I have to read the rules again because I'm completely lost :oops:
I did that because I was only voting for you because you had no votes, when someone else voted for you I quickly withdrew it and voted for someone else with no votes!
I was just an example, I wasn't asking you for explanations :-)
The only reason I can imagine to kill jblue is that the villains knew that she was a lover (so they kill two people with one shot) but that's impossible, isn't it?
There are a few things that I don't understand. Does the GL participate in the game? I thought that he only sends the roles and counts the votes.
The GL's only jobs are sending roles and counting votes like you said, but he can change things up a bit and introduce characters we don't know about if he wants to!
I think it's pretty unlikely that the villains knew JBlue and Stingray were lovers as I don't know how they possibly could know that. I just think they got VERY lucky killing two people instead of one!
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
That's actually a very good (and valid) point. He hasn't posted much today either has he? Flew right under the radar...
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
I think people changed their mind because they realised that what Brandon had said to get voted to begin with (about observing us all) was probably just a jokey comment, not a confession to being a villain!
I'm going to guess the two lovers conspired to vote for the same person?
Perhaps the four villains did the same? (This is a reach)
Well only 2 of them will know each other, but that's a good theory! :thumbup: that to me suggests lynn, jae and nilmade (2 of the 3) or me and proaluu (and I'm not a villain and I don't think proaluu is after they made a massive list last night).
It doesn't necessarily mean that's the case of course, but going off the 3 people who voted for the same person, I'm fairly sure Jae is innocent so that leaves Lynn and Nilmade...
I agree, two out of three from lynn, jae & nilmade could be possible villains
Would 1 stonecutter/alien vote for their stonecutter/alien counterpart to throw us off?
For instance say me and you are stonecutters Juliet, we could conspire to vote each other (as long as it wasn't damaging) to make it look like we are not part of a two
Does that make sense?
Yes. Juliet voted for me, proallu did the same and then Juliet changed her vote and voted for proallu, but seems that the GL didn't see that.
I have a headache after reading everything and I think I have to read the rules again because I'm completely lost :oops:
I did that because I was only voting for you because you had no votes, when someone else voted for you I quickly withdrew it and voted for someone else with no votes!
I was just an example, I wasn't asking you for explanations :-)
The only reason I can imagine to kill jblue is that the villains knew that she was a lover (so they kill two people with one shot) but that's impossible, isn't it?
There are a few things that I don't understand. Does the GL participate in the game? I thought that he only sends the roles and counts the votes.
The GL's only jobs are sending roles and counting votes like you said, but he can change things up a bit and introduce characters we don't know about if he wants to!
I think it's pretty unlikely that the villains knew JBlue and Stingray were lovers as I don't know how they possibly could know that. I just think they got VERY lucky killing two people instead of one!
I'm not sure about that juliet I just get this feeling that it wasn't a rendom pick, thats why I went back to her ;posts (only up to page 20 for now) to see who she suspected.
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
I think people changed their mind because they realised that what Brandon had said to get voted to begin with (about observing us all) was probably just a jokey comment, not a confession to being a villain!
Ok, that's true. He was a target because of something that was pretty obviously a joke. But I wonder... :?:
Basically, this game is giving me trust issues. Even the most convincingly honest people are starting to seem suspicious to me, because I know that at least 4 of them are lying through their teeth!
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
I think people changed their mind because they realised that what Brandon had said to get voted to begin with (about observing us all) was probably just a jokey comment, not a confession to being a villain!
As far as I'm remember (which isn't a lot btw) it was you who defended him was it not Juliet?
Perhaps you and Brandon are in cahoots...
Got a pretty busy afternoon / evening, so excuse me for not posting that much.
Few things:
Mainly for Johnny: i really dont think the GL would tell someone to give up their identity. That's the persons own doing.
As far as Wili's concerned: whether you are a villain or a protector, youre doing a pretty bad job either way. I really hope you are a villain because otherwise you signed a death warrant for one of the most valuable Springfielders. :? Way to go.
Not voting just yet since there's lots of time left but at this point i think my vote goes to Wilki as well.
Last thing: what's with all the ghosts? :P
Did they get a bigger role this time? I hope so, think that would be funny.
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
That's actually a very good (and valid) point. He hasn't posted much today either has he? Flew right under the radar...
I didn't say I was suspecting him again. I said the villains possibly think he innocent as well and would rather focus on finding villains.
I'm going to guess the two lovers conspired to vote for the same person?
Perhaps the four villains did the same? (This is a reach)
Well only 2 of them will know each other, but that's a good theory! :thumbup: that to me suggests lynn, jae and nilmade (2 of the 3) or me and proaluu (and I'm not a villain and I don't think proaluu is after they made a massive list last night).
It doesn't necessarily mean that's the case of course, but going off the 3 people who voted for the same person, I'm fairly sure Jae is innocent so that leaves Lynn and Nilmade...
I agree, two out of three from lynn, jae & nilmade could be possible villains
Would 1 stonecutter/alien vote for their stonecutter/alien counterpart to throw us off?
For instance say me and you are stonecutters Juliet, we could conspire to vote each other (as long as it wasn't damaging) to make it look like we are not part of a two
Does that make sense?
Yes. Juliet voted for me, proallu did the same and then Juliet changed her vote and voted for proallu, but seems that the GL didn't see that.
I have a headache after reading everything and I think I have to read the rules again because I'm completely lost :oops:
I did that because I was only voting for you because you had no votes, when someone else voted for you I quickly withdrew it and voted for someone else with no votes!
I was just an example, I wasn't asking you for explanations :-)
The only reason I can imagine to kill jblue is that the villains knew that she was a lover (so they kill two people with one shot) but that's impossible, isn't it?
There are a few things that I don't understand. Does the GL participate in the game? I thought that he only sends the roles and counts the votes.
The GL's only jobs are sending roles and counting votes like you said, but he can change things up a bit and introduce characters we don't know about if he wants to!
I think it's pretty unlikely that the villains knew JBlue and Stingray were lovers as I don't know how they possibly could know that. I just think they got VERY lucky killing two people instead of one!
I'm not sure about that juliet I just get this feeling that it wasn't a rendom pick, thats why I went back to her ;posts (only up to page 20 for now) to see who she suspected.
I didn't mean that they chose JBlue randomly, I just meant that I don't think they knew anything about the "lovers" thing, I think that part was just luck!
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
I think people changed their mind because they realised that what Brandon had said to get voted to begin with (about observing us all) was probably just a jokey comment, not a confession to being a villain!
Ok, that's true. He was a target because of something that was pretty obviously a joke. But I wonder... :?:
Basically, this game is giving me trust issues. Even the most convincingly honest people are starting to seem suspicious to me, because I know that at least 4 of them are lying through their teeth!
oh! Although this does lend more credence to Johnny's (I think it was Johnny...) statement that we should be paying more attention to the quiet people. Well, not necessarily the quiet people, but the ones who seem like they're trying to fly under the radar. Because maintaining lies takes energy, and every time a villain speaks, they risk blowing it...?
I'm going to guess the two lovers conspired to vote for the same person?
Perhaps the four villains did the same? (This is a reach)
Well only 2 of them will know each other, but that's a good theory! :thumbup: that to me suggests the people who have voted the same, which are lynn, jae and nilmade (2 of them) or me and proaluu (and I'm not a villain and I don't think proaluu is after they made a massive list last night).
It doesn't necessarily mean that's the case of course, but going off the 3 people who voted for the same person, I'm fairly sure Jae is innocent so that leaves Lynn and Nilmade...
Not only did proallu make that magnificent list (wowsers) but according to that vote list, he got 2 votes (I'd say he earned it after all that work)
USA/UK Race To Throw Country Into Utter Chaos = TOO CLOSE TO CALL
Basically, this game is giving me trust issues. Even the most convincingly honest people are starting to seem suspicious to me, because I know that at least 4 of them are lying through their teeth!
Haha I know! I couldn't believe it last time that Elian had been lying to me the whole time!
To give a reasoning on maybe why the villains targeted stingray and jblue is perhaps since they can pick from ANYONE they went for people that were not seen as villains and innocent.
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
I think people changed their mind because they realised that what Brandon had said to get voted to begin with (about observing us all) was probably just a jokey comment, not a confession to being a villain!
As far as I'm remember (which isn't a lot btw) it was you who defended him was it not Juliet?
Perhaps you and Brandon are in cahoots...
Quite a few people stood up for Brandon and Slayer because they both said silly things that made them look guilty but were obviously jokes! I was one of them yes because I did the same thing in the first game lol! Luckily only Wilki took me seriously
Replies
I did that because I was only voting for you because you had no votes, when someone else voted for you I quickly withdrew it and voted for someone else with no votes!
My reasoning is brandon who alot thought was bad then people started saying was good, so the villains skipped over him since, to me anyway, the want to find other villain team.
Annette was likewise skipped because the villains believe she is innocent
As well as Juliet, and proallu.
And if Wilki is telling truth then they skipped him as well.
Leaving whoever else is left in their eyes as a good group to pick from. If they didn't get a villain then oh well they at least narrowed their list down. And I believe it was just our bad luck they picked the lover which what juliet said kills both.
My theory anyway
The only reason I can imagine to kill jblue is that the villains knew that she was a lover (so they kill two people with one shot) but that's impossible, isn't it?
There are a few things that I don't understand. Does the GL participate in the game? I thought that he only sends the roles and counts the votes.
^i've actually been thinking a lot about this.
At the very beginning of our first day, Brandon was a target. For a while there, I was pretty sure he was the one going home. Then, people's attention wandered away from him, and he ended up with only one vote. Is that the natural ebb and flow of the game, or was there a specific moment that made that happen? I tried looking back, but there are SO MANY PAGES that I couldn't pinpoint the moment where people lost suspicion in him. Basically, is Brandon the luckiest guy in the world, a good negotiator, or did his villain counterpart bail him out? :shock:
The GL's only jobs are sending roles and counting votes like you said, but he can change things up a bit and introduce characters we don't know about if he wants to!
I think it's pretty unlikely that the villains knew JBlue and Stingray were lovers as I don't know how they possibly could know that. I just think they got VERY lucky killing two people instead of one!
That's actually a very good (and valid) point. He hasn't posted much today either has he? Flew right under the radar...
I think people changed their mind because they realised that what Brandon had said to get voted to begin with (about observing us all) was probably just a jokey comment, not a confession to being a villain!
I'm not sure about that juliet I just get this feeling that it wasn't a rendom pick, thats why I went back to her ;posts (only up to page 20 for now) to see who she suspected.
Ok, that's true. He was a target because of something that was pretty obviously a joke. But I wonder... :?:
Basically, this game is giving me trust issues. Even the most convincingly honest people are starting to seem suspicious to me, because I know that at least 4 of them are lying through their teeth!
As far as I'm remember (which isn't a lot btw) it was you who defended him was it not Juliet?
Perhaps you and Brandon are in cahoots...
Few things:
Mainly for Johnny: i really dont think the GL would tell someone to give up their identity. That's the persons own doing.
As far as Wili's concerned: whether you are a villain or a protector, youre doing a pretty bad job either way. I really hope you are a villain because otherwise you signed a death warrant for one of the most valuable Springfielders. :? Way to go.
Not voting just yet since there's lots of time left but at this point i think my vote goes to Wilki as well.
Last thing: what's with all the ghosts? :P
Did they get a bigger role this time? I hope so, think that would be funny.
I didn't say I was suspecting him again. I said the villains possibly think he innocent as well and would rather focus on finding villains.
I didn't mean that they chose JBlue randomly, I just meant that I don't think they knew anything about the "lovers" thing, I think that part was just luck!
oh! Although this does lend more credence to Johnny's (I think it was Johnny...) statement that we should be paying more attention to the quiet people. Well, not necessarily the quiet people, but the ones who seem like they're trying to fly under the radar. Because maintaining lies takes energy, and every time a villain speaks, they risk blowing it...?
Not only did proallu make that magnificent list (wowsers) but according to that vote list, he got 2 votes (I'd say he earned it after all that work)
Haha I know! I couldn't believe it last time that Elian had been lying to me the whole time!
Quite a few people stood up for Brandon and Slayer because they both said silly things that made them look guilty but were obviously jokes! I was one of them yes because I did the same thing in the first game lol! Luckily only Wilki took me seriously