[FR] [CD] Pet taken by Grim Reaper after beating him at Hopscotch

My elder dog died and my child challenged Grim at Hopscotch to keep my dog alive. My child won (after 5 ingame hours)  and grim lost and he still  took my pet💔.  Is this a glitch or will it sometimes happen? 

This was the first time I've ever tried it.  I know that Hopscotch comes with For Rent. 😅

Edit By crinrict: Added Tag to Title, Adjusted Title