[GTW] Carrot Cake Cannot Have Candles or Wedding Topper

I also experience this issue. It appears to be the 1 (and only) cake (unlike Fruitcake, Lava Bundt Cake, etc.) that your Sims can Bake.

Too bad, it's cute and perfect for fall! 🥕🎂🍁🍂

MISC INFO: Xbox Series X, all packs & pre-order content installed. Version 2.19.4.2310

I can't put a topper of any kind on the Blue Confetti Cake. 

I don't think I had this problem before the 11/04/25 update

Re: the status "Awaiting Additional Reports" please consider this feedback thread currently has 13+ likes Please add birthday options to baked goods | EA Forums - 12631720 

Carrot cake is a popular "grown up" birthday cake where I live, this would be a great fix to have.

Thank you :)

I have noticed that you cannot add birthday candles nor the wedding thing to the carrot cake as well