Forum Discussion

smugxb's avatar
smugxb
Seasoned Traveler
2 years ago

Re: Dumping the puck

@KidShowtime1867 I don't think this is the issue being discussed. Are these dumps? Technically speaking, yes they are. Is this what happens in hockey? Most often, no.

There are of course times when players want to soft dump the puck, yes, but mainly to burn time or get a change. Most other times, and specifically on the PK, NHL players are not soft dumping the puck like this. They are dumping either very high in the air, or very hard off the glass. 

The dumps shown are extremely subdued, and kids playing hockey can dump the puck harder and higher than this. I think that's what these other posters are aiming for in their posts as well. 

Further, the CPU still can't clear the puck effectively, and routinely their clears are caught by the opposing team. Also, 6v6, the soft clears are just corralled by the opposing team and brought right back in. This may work in VS, but it is not as effective in 6v6.

We don't even bother with this anymore and either pass, slapshot, or wrist it out to clear. Although you sometimes still have the unrealistic play of skaters grabbing a slapshot out of the air. 🤦

So yes, while you can dump the puck in this game, this is just being semantical. High hard dumps do not exist in this game in the traditional sense. This is a real hockey play and should be in the game.

That's the contention here and it's already been said that this was done to enable the pressure system to work better.

3 Replies

  • I see 20 clips of dumping the puck working and 0 clips of it not working 🤷‍♂️

  • RelentlessJ69's avatar
    RelentlessJ69
    New Hotshot
    2 years ago
    @KidShowtime1867 I just don't care to upload the clips of the AI not being able to dump the puck only to have the opposing team catch it before it leaves the zone 99% of the time because its already been established that EA doesn't want puck dumps to take away from the pressure system lol.
  • KidShowtime1867's avatar
    KidShowtime1867
    Hero
    2 years ago

    @RelentlessJ69 wrote:
    @KidShowtime1867I just don't care to upload the clips of the AI not being able to dump the puck only to have the opposing team catch it before it leaves the zone 99% of the time because its already been established that EA doesn't want puck dumps to take away from the pressure system lol.

    Show a clip so the team knows what exactly the issue is 🤷‍♂️

About NHL 24 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and talk with us about your experiences in NHL 24.4,284 PostsLatest Activity: 2 years ago