Superstar ‘Play Game’ Buttons

Just got traded from the Steelers to the Patriots in Week 12. I’m seeing two ‘Play Game’ buttons and both of them take me to the Steelers matchup instead of my NE vs NYJ game. 
While looking at the Steelers matchup there is no other option for me but to back out into the Superstar Home Screen. 
I’ve spent a few bucks on this character and can’t even play a single game anymore. This game is so trash