Forum Discussion
Some more really "sim" gameplay from online versus:
@Jagavekov wrote:Some more really "sim" gameplay from online versus:
1 missed poke
2 missed pokes
And a defender skating into his other defender and the goalie, preventing anyone from seeing that puck coming through:
And finally, a player with all of the open ice in the world to do whatever they want, completely unimpeded. You'll also notice the puck carriers feet aren't moving, they're holding the puck forehand to increase their agility, balance, etc and they use all of that to make a good play.
What do you think is wrong with this play?
- couture2fat2fly2 years agoSeasoned Veteran@KidShowtime1867 I'd just like to point out that the game doesn't have to be 1:1 sim nor full on arcade. It is always going to be somewhere in the middle and everyone knows that, but there is no question that this year's version is much less realistic than last year's.
This is not normal and it indicates exactly what Jagavekov is saying: "...some of the reasons this game is horrible are simply choices that have been made, likely misguided attempts to cater to the lowest common denominator of potential customer."
By comparison, we had a realistic game in the past so arguments such as "how lucky we are to even have a game, its a miracle" and "do you realize how hard it is to make code" are invalid. The game is unrealistic because EA is steering it that way.
Easy fix, as proposed, would be to have different modes. I know you swear by OVP as being the gold standard, but I guarantee you interceptions and pokechecks are just as completely ineffective there as they are in HUT/EASHL and the same glitches can be found in every single mode. It's all by design. - couture2fat2fly2 years agoSeasoned Veteran@KidShowtime1867 "What do you think is wrong with this play?" There are 2 defenders in the passing lane (oh ok sorry, a whole foot outside the actual trajectory of the puck, terrible defense...) and none of them is able to cut that very obvious pass.
- couture2fat2fly2 years agoSeasoned Veteran
Look at just a few clips of a game I played, I believe this is a good example of how the game has been dumbed down to cater to casual players. Legit plays being punished and dumb plays being rewarded.
https://youtu.be/qYSgJO1ZvvA?si=9jGNgrx_1JTXccbF
https://youtu.be/r3IApAWnpvo?si=Mj31zxgqceU9eRAu
- Jagavekov2 years agoSeasoned Veteran
@couture2fat2fly wrote:Look at just a few clips of a game I played, I believe this is a good example of how the game has been dumbed down to cater to casual players. Legit plays being punished and dumb plays being rewarded.
https://youtu.be/qYSgJO1ZvvA?si=9jGNgrx_1JTXccbF
https://youtu.be/r3IApAWnpvo?si=Mj31zxgqceU9eRAu
https://youtu.be/kfe2OraPo28?si=JCSpAPa6lpcWFfvo
https://youtu.be/nB-Y-PvuIBY?si=PSe4BzHkFJS5-G7m
Brutal. Those clips show that not only is the "exhaust engine" gimmicky, arcadey, and inauthentic, it doesn't even do what it was supposed to do. Puck movement resulting in high quality shots from high-danger areas were not rewarded, but forcing passes and one on one figure skating were.
About NHL 24 General Discussion
Recent Discussions
NHL 25 on PS4 and PS5
Solved28 days ago