Nhl 24 the game for everyone and anyone.
This used to be a game that took skill to be good at. Many of us have spent decades trying to master the skills to get where we are now. It's more than obvious that EA have given up on us loyal fan...
Forum Discussion
Well, showing videos to you doesnt make any sense, you have seen a lot of poke checking and interceptions absoutelly not working and you are still repeating, that its working fine and everything is users fault :D Dont know why, but you are blindly (and very often comically) defending the game and throwing down every proves that the defending in the game is bad.
@Losoun wrote:you have seen a lot of poke checking and interceptions absoutelly not working
Show me one.
I've posted this one before ( there's two clips in the video, only the first is relevant ). Offensive player exposes the puck and it should be a trivial play to poke the puck away. The puck is both accurate and strong enough to knock his stick away, but somehow completely misses the puck. Couldn't pull that off on-ice if I tried but it's a regular occurrence in this game.
Two for interceptions. First one I've got inside position with my stick on the ice, just somehow miss the puck entirely while the offensive player just inches past my stick picks it up clean and gets a shot off.
Second it a bit more forgivable, but still frustrating. Again, inside position but instead of breaking up the pass while it's in front of me, the game decides I'll try to pick it off on the far side of my body which opens up the opportunity for the offensive player to get the puck and the goal.
@PlayoffError wrote:I've posted this one before ( there's two clips in the video, only the first is relevant ). Offensive player exposes the puck and it should be a trivial play to poke the puck away. The puck is both accurate and strong enough to knock his stick away, but somehow completely misses the puck. Couldn't pull that off on-ice if I tried but it's a regular occurrence in this game.
Two for interceptions. First one I've got inside position with my stick on the ice, just somehow miss the puck entirely while the offensive player just inches past my stick picks it up clean and gets a shot off.
Second it a bit more forgivable, but still frustrating. Again, inside position but instead of breaking up the pass while it's in front of me, the game decides I'll try to pick it off on the far side of my body which opens up the opportunity for the offensive player to get the puck and the goal.
Finally, someone pulls through. Of course, these are from HUT. As I've said time and time again; realism down to the pixel should not be expected in HUT. No attribute parity, top players are all similarly skilled.. RNG will be more consequential than it should be.
- @KidShowtime1867 These are from club games. I don't play HUT.
@PlayoffError wrote:
@KidShowtime1867These are from club games. I don't play HUT.Fair enough.
Is it so hard to see for the team and everyone that this i a very bad hockey game that is just full of bugs ? I have tried 100 Times to play this game but I cant stad play it anymore . It is bad in every single way and there is no action left in the game, even the menus is slow and crappy . I cant understand why i got like this ?
u cant say enough about this game..
Worst gameplay and changes ever. This game was soo good previous years but not anymore. Of course few bugs was previous years but the gameplay was fun to play. Now the gameplay is arcade whit the un realistic speed hitting, AI is so bad and many more. Game rewards players Who just shoot and hit all the time.
And u can do Michigan goal and other fancy stuff whit ONE button? Are u kidding? :D u have to master the skills, moves and how to play and score playing the game and not like this that everyone can do Michigan when ever they want just Pressin one button.
@KidShowtime1867 wrote:
@PlayoffError wrote:I've posted this one before ( there's two clips in the video, only the first is relevant ). Offensive player exposes the puck and it should be a trivial play to poke the puck away. The puck is both accurate and strong enough to knock his stick away, but somehow completely misses the puck. Couldn't pull that off on-ice if I tried but it's a regular occurrence in this game.
Two for interceptions. First one I've got inside position with my stick on the ice, just somehow miss the puck entirely while the offensive player just inches past my stick picks it up clean and gets a shot off.
Second it a bit more forgivable, but still frustrating. Again, inside position but instead of breaking up the pass while it's in front of me, the game decides I'll try to pick it off on the far side of my body which opens up the opportunity for the offensive player to get the puck and the goal.
Finally, someone pulls through. Of course, these are from HUT. As I've said time and time again; realism down to the pixel should not be expected in HUT. No attribute parity, top players are all similarly skilled.. RNG will be more consequential than it should be.
Brother, you can't beg for videos every time someone criticizes the game and then say, "No, not those videos!" C'mon, man.
Idk man. You really "dissected" that dude's videos by saying they were HUT clips and therefore didn't make sense and then when he responded with, "No actually the clips are from club," you just said, "fair enough." I don't think that's a good faith discussion, honestly.
@NeonSkyline21 wrote:
@KidShowtime1867 wrote:
@PlayoffError wrote:I've posted this one before ( there's two clips in the video, only the first is relevant ). Offensive player exposes the puck and it should be a trivial play to poke the puck away. The puck is both accurate and strong enough to knock his stick away, but somehow completely misses the puck. Couldn't pull that off on-ice if I tried but it's a regular occurrence in this game.
Two for interceptions. First one I've got inside position with my stick on the ice, just somehow miss the puck entirely while the offensive player just inches past my stick picks it up clean and gets a shot off.
Second it a bit more forgivable, but still frustrating. Again, inside position but instead of breaking up the pass while it's in front of me, the game decides I'll try to pick it off on the far side of my body which opens up the opportunity for the offensive player to get the puck and the goal.
Finally, someone pulls through. Of course, these are from HUT. As I've said time and time again; realism down to the pixel should not be expected in HUT. No attribute parity, top players are all similarly skilled.. RNG will be more consequential than it should be.
Brother, you can't beg for videos every time someone criticizes the game and then say, "No, not those videos!" C'mon, man.
Idk man. You really "dissected" that dude's videos by saying they were HUT clips and therefore didn't make sense and then when he responded with, "No actually the clips are from club," you just said, "fair enough." I don't think that's a good faith discussion, honestly.
This is why I've taken an "anti video" stance on this site. Videos are always requested to discuss "x" but when videos are uploaded, the "x" that the OP wanted to discuss is rarely discussed and the video starts being nitpicked for "y", "z", and everything else that can be seen.
The community needs to be comfortable with discussion HIGH LEVEL concepts without a video. If a video is requested, the OP point NEEDS to be discussed. Not the missed the poke, not the clipping, not the less than optimal decision making, not the game mode and why you can't expect "x" because of "insert game mode here" explanation, but the actual main point of why the video was uploaded.
When these videos are nitpicked to death and essentially dismissed due to "skill issue bro" it forfeits all opportunity to gain anything constructive from the topic at hand. If we all can't talk about the theory of how this game should look and feel without video, then what are we all doing here? If we can't agree on the fundamental direction of the series in theory, how can we properly provide feedback to the development team?
Thank you for the addition. Let's keep this positive approach rolling and get the devs some actionable, constructive feedback!
