Forum Discussion

PernellKarl027's avatar
2 years ago

ONLINE vs OFFLINE

This is gonna be a long read, so bear with me. I would also like for this thread to be constructive šŸ˜€

First of all, I feel that there seems to be allot of confusion when people ask questions or have concerns on the game as to where these might fit, ONLINE or OFFLINE. For many parts of the game, these are two different beasts.


I also have the feeling that EA tries to please each and everyone in the same package and that’s near impossible. Because we have a good SIM portion hiding in there and there’s everything an Arcade freak would want. But it’s when you try to combine both in that said package that it screws everything up and brings tons of confusion like you see around these parts in the last few days….

You can only EXCEL in one subject, instead of being AVERAGE on multiple ones.

Why not make two different versions of the game ? And both at a reduced price of let’s say $40.  Pretty sure the 2 versions would outsell that only 1 and on top of it, EA will still have their MTX in the ONLINE version. Heck they could even do MTX in OFFLINE for Franchise modes or BAP.

This could leave OFFLINE people to swallow the pill much easier in terms of what was not touched in the game for the longest time. And ONLINE people would also pay a reduce price to start and grow on this after for these Micro Transactions they prefer…

Now here me out. One game could be the ONLINE version where you can call it NHL24 HITZ, NHL24 STREET or whatever. In that version, you could have:

- Basically what it is now. HUT, WOC and EASHL.

- Pressure Meter and everything that comes with it to force people to play a bit more like the real game.

- Micro Transactions to fulfill the need of everyone and everything, from clown suits to Green fluorescent uniforms.

- Goal Cellys, Flex Cam or Personalized dance people wants to perform.

- Short intros or even no intros at all.

- Sliders and settings for that version.

- TUNERS and PATCHES/UPDATE for that said mode. Cause often times, these updates screw up the OFFLINE portion. Trust me !

Now for the OFFLINE portion:

- Way Longer intros.

- Goalies Presentations with stats at the beginning of each game.

- A way better simulation of that beautiful sport and what it represents.

- Better Franchise mode in all aspects and player likeness.

- Better BAP

- Slider Presets that would please real hockey freaks.

- Tuners/Updates that would reflect the OFFLINE portion only.

As for myself, I’ve been a loyal customer since NHL91 and this year will be the first year I won’t buy the game. Cause as mentioned above, I’m CONFUSED šŸ˜• I’ve seen very nice strides in the right direction, so KUDOS for that EA šŸ‘šŸ¼ But on the other hand, I feel that you’ve taken 10 steps back in other areas. I’ve made my points in other threads, this is not the place for this here…

So here were my thoughts on all of this and I think that it would be a very good thing for NHL25. NHL25 HITZ and NHL25 CORE šŸ˜€

Heck, I’ll run the Offline portion for FREE if you want, and I’m dead serious šŸ˜€ What do you have to lose ?

6 Replies

  • Cote12's avatar
    Cote12
    New Vanguard
    2 years ago

    As a fellow offline player, I support this! Heck, I’m  on board to join your team šŸ˜‚ 

    I’ve been coming in hot this week so I’ll try to remain calm and constructive. But I do feel as though the game is not playable offline right now. And that makes me sad. I just want to get lost in franchise mode and take a break from life once in a while. But the game is so dang zippy and arcady and clunky.

  • I 100% agree with all you said! 

    I just wish that the people from EA also read this and give an opinion/answer to it.

    But I'm afraid EA's new clarity/openness/transparency doesn't go that far, does it?

  • 75fd980e1b183900's avatar
    75fd980e1b183900
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago

    No. There is a huge 6s community that plays online and does not want fortnite celebrations, leprechaun costumes, or tacky sounds after goals.

    That stuff should be put into the 3v3 modes online and all 6s modes, online and offline, should be closer to sim hockey.

  • PernellKarl027's avatar
    PernellKarl027
    2 years ago

    @75fd980e1b183900 wrote:

    No. There is a huge 6s community that plays online and does not want fortnite celebrations, leprechaun costumes, or tacky sounds after goals.

    That stuff should be put into the 3v3 modes online and all 6s modes, online and offline, should be closer to sim hockey.


    Well you get the point I was trying to make. There would be a version more on the ARCADE, FORTNITE side of things and whatever and a CORE Version.

    And when you say ''NO'', think about it a bit more, you now paid what for the game ? A $100, $130 ? You still LOSE in the end, because they will not remove the "fortnite celebrations, leprechaun costumes, or tacky sounds after goals." Or even the sounds it makes when you pass the puck, or, or, or…

    That thread was not to put people in a certain category or to discriminate. Heck, you could buy BOTH versions since it would about equal in price as a COMPLETE version. You could play the version that suits you best that day…

    But that being said, I know lots of people that only wants to play ONLINE and peeps that ONLY play OFFLINE modes… So it would be a WIN-WIN.

    And when you talk about 6's, I would gladly JOIN the ONLINE peeps if it was more on the CORE side šŸ˜€


  • @Cote12 wrote:

    As a fellow offline player, I support this! Heck, I’m  on board to join your team šŸ˜‚ 

    I’ve been coming in hot this week so I’ll try to remain calm and constructive. But I do feel as though the game is not playable offline right now. And that makes me sad. I just want to get lost in franchise mode and take a break from life once in a while. But the game is so dang zippy and arcady and clunky.


    @Cote12 

    Hey man ! Yeah, I’ve been coming in hot myself on this game, this week, but that’s what is called PASSION, and I see that you have some too šŸ˜€ That would be one of my first prerequisite if you would want to join my team šŸ˜‰ So that’s a good start. I’ve got you on my radar 🧐

Featured Places

Node avatar for NHL 24 General Discussion

NHL 24 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and talk with us about your experiences in NHL 24.Latest Activity: 26 days ago
4,287 Posts