How do I recover lost profile data on Battlefield 4 (Xbox 360)?

I recently signed in to Xbox live and started Battlefield 4. After pressing start on the initial screen, I was asked to make screen adjustments. I did and saw that Battlefield was congratulating me for the Night Operations DLC a second time and was giving me the Battle Log introduction again. When I went to check my weapons, only the initial set was present and the game showed that I had no rank or other stats. I immediately closed the game, checked my save data, and saw that my older save was replaced by one made on this day, with no other saves present. 

Battlelog is showing that I am still level 55 and all of my prior history is still present. How do I restore or recover my profile if that is the case?