@Alastairhufc the quali can get depressing at times, but honestly I've come to blame it more and more on the TV broadcast. Noticed it recently while watching onboards in other categories and even on simracing.
I'd love to see more onboards with live commentary from pundits.
Those tracking shots from barriers are doing a disservice to F1, honestly. I'm referring to those shots close to the track, just behind the fence, where the camera operator tracks the car with the camera. They undersell the speeds and the work those drivers are putting out to handle those cars on the limit.
Wide shots for race action, onboards for push laps. Fewer tracking shots from the barriers. Those are my top items in my broadcast wishlist 🙏
Oh, let's throw that horrendous onboard graphics out of the window too!
Regarding your suggestions, I'm a little biased towards the current format. Besides the broadcast being suboptimal as I said, this is the format that gave us that spectacular Monaco quali - one of my all time F1 sessions!
What I love about it:
- Having cars on quali trim. Low fuel, no care for tyre saving. Seeing these machines operating at the highest single lap performance output they can. That also helps with the racing as cars with an unbalanced quali pace vs race pace performance relationship would often have interesting strategies and battles on Sunday
- Traffic. Spicy.
- Having all cars able to go out under optimal track conditions. I'm not too keen to see Max wasting his go on a relatively green track. I want to see top drivers wrangling every drop of performance out of their cars in the fastest state the track can get
ERS would not allow for 2 consecutive push laps as regs make it so that the maximum and minimum state of charge of the ES can never be greater than 4MJ.
Tyres also have such a narrow operational window two push consecutive push laps would probably be unfeasible depending on the compound. And putting them on a harder compound of having the drivers hold back on their banker lap would detract from my points above (100% effort laps).
Miami is a dull track though. My gut feeling is that anything would look lame on it. I'll definitely agree with you that this quali was dour.