Hey folks,
Thank you for your detailed feedback on this topic. We've shared an update on this which you can find here: Tyre Allocations - Answer HQ.
This is definitely one of those things that is getting more ridiculous as time goes on. Didn't feel so bad at launch, but now it's got to the point where every single race feels like it's playing out exactly the same. Sometimes I get to make a 2-second decision about running hard/medium instead of medium/hard (usually if I'm towards the back of the grid). The AI is always on the same tire too, making it feel like most of the races are playing out the same way.
I also find it funny that the tire selection is SO limited, that to switch to hard/medium, you can't just swap them (there aren't any spare tires to do that!). You have to first add a third stint, change the first stint to soft, then the second one to hard, the first one to medium and then delete the third stint. Tedious.
Finally, I ended up in a ridiculous situation at Canada the other night on a 50% race: I'd started on medium and had already done my pit stop onto hard. I was running out at the front of the grid in a small group of cars that were a significant distance away from the rest of the pack. 18 laps towards the end we get a safety car, so I decide to gamble on a new set of tires.... But what tires?!
So I had no choice but to keep going. Another set of mediums here would have been perfect and felt like a reasonable gamble. Instead the safety car came and went and nothing changed. Really boring situation to be in.
