Unable to select captain in online draft

On PC with only keyboard enabled for controls. I have just started FUT a few days ago and got a number of draft tokens so I thought I'd use one for an online draft. But once I get to the captain selection (after selecting a formation) I can't toggle between the available captains. No single key works to select another captain and mouse also doesn't work. I really don't want the selected captain, so I really want to switch...

I can't take a screenshot with the suggested ways to take a screenshot and prtscr makes the game crash...

Game runs fine otherwise.

Any ideas?