10 Complaints about Madden 25 Superstar Mode

1) AI Generated Players duplicates: Genuinely ridiculous that theres only 15-20 game faces for new young AI gen players. How lazy can EA be I have 5 guys on my team who look identical its so unrealistic. Then you go look at season stats and you see your players faces on other teams too its just ridiculous, how hard can it be to generate some cartoon faces I truly wonder what goes on inside EA headquarters sometimes no disrespect I want the game to get better but dear god its 2025 and a billion dollar company can only generate 15 faces its honestly more sad when you think about it. Moving on.

2) Cutscenes are insanely repetitive its a joke

Theres like 5 total cutscenes in this game. Its 2025. What are we doing? The players dont even talk its just subtitles which is fine i guess but atleast give us some variation I swear if my star player tells me to “get my popcorn ready” one more time ima crashout. 

3) ABILITY TO DECIDE TO GO FOR IT ON 4TH AND 1, O-LINE COACHES ARE IMBECILES

Oh my god dude the amount of times we have a 4th and 1 or INCHES at the opposing 40 yard line and we get pulled to punt just for them to get a touchback and start a drive at the 30 yard line make it make sense.

Give us a “force 4th down” button or something that allows us to tell our coach we want to go for it. One of the worst things about the game mode.

4) TEAMS MAKE AWFUL/ NO SIGNINGS DURING OFFSEASON

Tell me why when I win a super bowl (on all-madden difficulty too) my team then dosnt make one single singing in the offseason. And if we do make a signing its always someone low rated. Makes 0 sense. Im on my 9th season and i swear almost every off-season my team loses a star receiver and REPLACES THEM WITH NOBODY. I also see on my team roster well have like 1 player per position sometimes, especially on defense. And why is my kicker always <80 rated we cant afford anybody better as super bowl champs?

5) Ability to watch defensive simulation

Would love to see my defense in action and kickers. Ability to skip plays would be vital but Id honestly sit back and watch my defense play sometimes. 

6) Injuries 

Injuries on back to back plays seems ridiculous I had to turn them off because my star players get hurt every other game. Whatever.

7) MVP award is rigged you have to have the season of your life they always give it to random QBs who dont even make playoffs or lose the super bowl. Whatever tho Im only here for the rings I play for the team

8) Salaries make no sense

Im a famous star QB best in the world but can only make about 50 million a year wheras my teammates make significantlyyyyyyyy more. Dosnt really matter since the money you earn means nothing but still. 

9) “News” Tab

If @MberryEA tweets about making changes to the fantasy lineup 1 more time Im crashing out. 

10) Add a “fantasy” Tab

Tracking how many fantasy points you and youre team would’ve earned each week would be so cool. no shot it happens but everyone loves fantasy so if that was integrated in the game it would be so class.