Can't export a 2nd player to Madden

I have 2 CBs in CFB25, One was exported to Madden and I didn't like how it turned out. So I deleted it (the Madden CB) and tried to send the other CB (the CFB) one to Madden and it said that it can't transfer to Madden. 

Is there a way to get past this?

It wouldn't make any sense to only be able to send one player.