Can't play 2pt conversions

This wasn't an issue in Madden 24 so I don't understand how it can be an issue now but it is. I've not even played a full season yet and this issue has already screwed me over countless times.

I've got a QB superstar career and there's been multiple times where I've been down 7 and got a TD with seconds on the clock, CPU decides to go for 2pt conversion, but I don't get to actually play it? I just have to watch the simulation tell me that my QB failed a rush. If I knew that I wouldn't be able to play the conversion I'd just go for a FG but I can't decide that either.

This is so infuriating I never had a problem with this on Madden 24 and I hope it can be fixed.