You’re definitely not alone. I’ve been documenting a lot of the same issues in Superstar: ridiculous suction, wide open drops, absurd interceptions, forced situational games, questionable CPU behavior and games that constantly seem engineered to stay close.
What’s frustrating is CFB 27 RTG proves EA can make a player career mode that mostly just lets you PLAY FOOTBALL without constantly manipulating the experience.
But EA isn’t going to seriously address Superstar while we’re all complaining individually and everybody keeps buying anyway. The Cap Breaker mess in CFB got attention because enough of the community got behind the same complaint at the same time.
That’s probably what Madden needs. Not another 500 separate posts EA can ignore. One issue, one message, and enough players behind it that they can’t.