@EA_Blueberry
I just encountered the same issue. I have an amazon basics (off brand) xbox controller. However, I have tried a stock controller as well and no luck.
I am on PC and have uninstalled Origin, and Madden and tried moving them around to different drives with no luck.
Here is a clip of what it looks like.
Another note, I downloaded the Xbox Accessories App and it let me change my button mapping. I made it to where the two trigger inputs were swapped.
This caused the "Stall" when i want to snap the ball, to instead show the play art, and player stamina stats (as if i was holding down the Left trigger, instead of the Right trigger, which shows the X factors). (i did not do that in this clip though).
It seems that the error occurring is just a constant input of the right trigger. PLEASE HELP as the game is UNPLAYABLE.
Here is the link to my drop box, the file was too large.
The clip shows me navigating the menu with the controller. Everything working properly until i get in game.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/6579qvy1rgavbs4/Madden%20NFL%2020%202020-02-15%2023-10-40.mp4?dl=0