PC thinks I have two controllers but only one is plugged in.

My PC is recognizing two controllers when I only have one plugged in. I cant play franchise mode at all my team is always auto selected and I can only act as a second player or my opponent.  In the screenshot I posted the ONLY CONTROLLER I HAVE ACTIVE IN BLUETOOTH is the red controller icon.  I have removed all other controllers previously used on this machine.  It is an xbox series x controller that has been updated.