[The Yard] Challenge won't complete in Campaign "The Kittle Mash"

I am having an issue completing a challenge on the Yard in Campaign mode. The challenge falls in Chapter 2, under "The Kittle Mash." It is the second to last game In "The Kittle Mash", called "Glowing Up." The challenge is to "Make a SIDELINE POSSESSION Catch." No matter what I do, the challenge is never completed and I make possession catch after possesion catch on the sidelines. Whether it's the tip toe and fall out of bounds, I possession and fall right at the sidelines, etc. The challenge just does not complete. I'm a perfectionist so it irks me a little that I can't complete it. If anyone can look into it and give me feedback, I would greatly appreciate it!

[EDIT: removed formatting; modified thread title to improve visibility/clarity]