Forum Discussion

drewgriffiths's avatar
drewgriffiths
Seasoned Veteran
2 years ago

Unrealistic Penalty?

Before I start, I don’t have any video to show this so you’ll need to take my description for this. I was playing a Franchise Mode game (as a 33rd team bringing back the Hartford Whalers) where I was 5-1 up late in the third when a penalty is called on a CPU controlled player on my team and when I do touch the puck, I see its a 5 minute major. Wanting to see what happened for such penalty, I wait for the replay and what it shows still puzzles me. What happens is my captain Brent Burns is in front of his own net and gives the opposing player in front enough of a shove for him to fall down with no other player close enough. The player is unhurt, but Burnsy gets a 5 minute major for interference. However, despite the penalty, I still run out the clock for a 5-1 win. Surely this penalty is unrealistic, right?

Whats the silliest and most unrealistic penalties you’ve seen, not just on NHL 23 but also previous games too?

8 Replies

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    2 years ago

    Hi there, @drewgriffiths 

    Thanks for reporting this. If it happens again, please try to get some video. That's really crucial, but I'll pass on the feedback.

  • Did it happen during or after the attempted touchpass? It could be that you manually controlled Burns to do a hit by accident.

    In any case I can believe the AI was too aggressive and went for an unwarranted hit - they randomly do that in EASHL as well but I don't think it's ever caused an injury, just interference

  • drewgriffiths's avatar
    drewgriffiths
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago
    @TTZ_Dipsy I was controlling another player attempting to merely position myself right. I wasn’t attempting to hit anyone with who I thought I was controlling, nor stick lift or stick check, just positioning as I was 5-1 up with about 4 minutes left.

    Just a VERY strange penalty.
  • drewgriffiths's avatar
    drewgriffiths
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago
    @EA_Aljo I’ll get some video if I ever see it again though it’s the first time I’ve been so baffled by a penalty, I’m not sure I’ll see anything like it again 😆 (I zoned out when it happened because it’s Superstar AI with the diff adjustments maxed out and I wanted to keep that 5-1 lead 👍🏼)

    Maybe someone else sees this who does have some video of something similar 🤞🏼
  • drewgriffiths's avatar
    drewgriffiths
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago
    @EA_Aljo No problem.

    …just before I end there. Take a look at this >>> https://youtu.be/Yrczbk7AChs … no penalty was called and I think its seen as incidental contact by the game, but I believe it should be called as a tripping penalty and here’s where I’ll tread with caution. Maybe make it an option in the sliders? I’m sure the bright minds upstairs at EA can figure it out but you can see where I’m coming from. I lost the game 3-1 (played like an amateur) but my goal is here >>> https://youtu.be/GSq__7a-0c8 … feel free to roast my Whalers uniforms, horn and goal song 😆
  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    2 years ago

    @drewgriffiths 

    You only get a tripping call for using the stick so this would be incidental. I shudder to think what would happen if we had tripping calls for incidental contact 😮

  • drewgriffiths's avatar
    drewgriffiths
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago
    @EA_Aljo Maybe I’m wishing for TOO MUCH realism, right 😆

    … I’ll start the hunt for my old CCM skates, fish around eBay for equipment and hit the ice for real again at my ripe age of 44 😆