Forum Discussion

Collesium_king's avatar
Collesium_king
Seasoned Newcomer
1 year ago

ATTENTION ALL MODS

The system of suspending and/or banning accounts is absolutely broken and killing the community.

I will not go into the finite details of my recent ban, although it was completely non-sensical and violated no part of the player charter, appealing the specific ban is not the point of this post. I will use it as an example to highlight my concerns and address the processes in place.

My personal player account was banned for a club name. I appealed; the bots who reviewed gave a canned answer that "my account was actioned correctly".

1) If someone is breaking a rule it would seem to me that it behooves all parties to understand what and/or how the rule was broken. Your current methodology does neither.

2) How is banning a player account a remedy to a club name (this part gets better keep reading)?

            - Though my account was banned the club name was not forced to be changed

            - The club was actually allowed to continue playing

            - Even now once my WEEK ban (for a first offense) is over, the club's name cannot be changed and is still in existence!

3) If you are going to say something violates the player charter, how do you then not create a pathway to remedy that violation?

4) I was the club creator, nothing I can do will change the fact my name is listed as such (including leaving the club). So, am I just to get continually banned for something I cannot change? Especially something that as I mentioned did not actually violate any portion of the player charter. As a side note we have used this exact name since NHL 19.

As another example to the ridiculousness of this process. A friend was banned because his skater's name was Mike Vick. A guy who is FEATURED on other EA products and was the cover athlete for one of the seasons of Madden Ultimate team this year and using his name violates the EA Player Charter?!?!? 

As a 30 year EA customer I'm begging you MAKE IT MAKE SENSE!

4 Replies

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    1 year ago

    Hello, @Collesium_king 

    Thanks for reporting this. Should it happen in the future, please let me know. Send me a private message with the details of your ban and I'll have it looked into. Appreciate the feedback.

  • Collesium_king's avatar
    Collesium_king
    Seasoned Newcomer
    1 year ago

    Hello!! Unfortunately the website will not allow me to direct message you. Constantly gives a flag error. So the information is below.

    First off let me say thank you for even being willing to look into this. The mechanisms EA has in place for such a large enterprise are underwhelming to say the least. Below is the direct copy & paste from the e-mail I received for my ban.


    After thoroughly investigating your account and concern, we found that your account was actioned correctly and will not remove this sanction from your account.

    For clarity this is the name of a town and our area code.

    As I said in my forum post, my point was not to necessarily appeal my specific ban. Although it would be great if it was removed from my account. The point is to point out the complete lack of a viable process to address and actually resolve issues. Also to ensure I do not continually get banned for something I cannot change. Even if I leave the club it will always show my name as founder. So, am I to be continually banned every time there is a bogus report because some team is mad they were beaten?

    In this case my personal EA/player account was banned for a club name, and yes, I am the club creator. However, if I am going to be punished for a name that we have used every year since 2019, should there not be mechanism to change the club name? Instead, no action was taken in that regard and the club was actually free to continue playing games while I was suspended.

    I do know people whose club name was deemed offensive and all that was done was when they logged in, they were greeted with a pop-up message that stated the name was deemed in violation of the rules and they were forced to simply change the name. No personal accounts were banned or actioned against. 

    If the club name needs to be changed so be it, but to punish a player account? It doesn't compute.

    The system of what is and is not in violation seems very arbitrary. As I mentioned in my forum post, a friend who used the skater name of Mike Vick was banned for that. When Mike Vick is used every year in the Madden Ultimate Team and was actually the poster athlete for one of the seasons of Madden 24, but in another EA product using his name gets you suspended?

    Again, thank you for your time and willingness to look into this. Please let me know if you need any other amplifying information.

    Edit: Removed account details. Do not post this on public forums. -CM

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    1 year ago

    @Collesium_king 

    Unfortunately, I can't help without your gamertag/PSN ID. I need that sent via private message. I've never heard of that error when messaging us. Can you get me a screenshot of it? You should be able to go to my profile and hit the letter icon in the upper left to PM me.

  • Nolan1738cool's avatar
    Nolan1738cool
    Seasoned Novice
    1 year ago

    Did you guys look into intros from nhl 14 and to bring them back in nhl 25 with full presentation intros?

Featured Places

Node avatar for NHL 24 General Discussion

NHL 24 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and talk with us about your experiences in NHL 24.Latest Activity: 3 days ago
4,284 Posts