NHL 24 Franchise mode is unplayable on superstar

Mess with your sliders, specifically the shooting category. I have the same problem. To keep the CPU in the same shots to goals ratio, you’ll need to drop the CPU’s shooting by at least 10-15. If the CPU has a rating of 50, the CPU will have. 30% shooting percentage all the time. 

I also change up both User and CPU goalie sliders, quite a bit to add more realism. 

hope this helps.