Forum Discussion

jlnhl2001's avatar
jlnhl2001
New Vanguard
27 days ago

Generated Player Names suck, and here's why

A while back, when editing the databases of NHL 20, I came across a breakthrough in regards to how generated player names work, and why teh names generally suck.

The names are separated into banks; Canada, Quebec, Czechia, Slovakia, Germany, Russia, Sweden, Finland, and United States. If a generated player’s country isn’t any of these, the game defaults to the American name bank, hence why a player from Norway can be named Marshall Mathers. Yes, this actually happened to me once, in the previously mentioned NHL 20. I had an entire Twitter thread detailing the games in which this was a thing, dating all the way back to NHL 07 on the Xbox 360, but I wound up deleting all my accounts there because Elon Musk sucks. However, I did take screenshots of examples of this.

The way I would fix this is simply to borrow the way they work in FIFA, as NHL has a history of borrowing from either that series or Madden. If that's not possible, then at least add in new banks to accomodate those regions.

I included screenshots from NHL 07, NHL 13, NHL 14 (where I edited the banks in the hopes of fixing some of this), NHL 15, NHL 16, NHL 20, NHL 24, and NHL 25 to show all of you just how long this has gone unnoticed. Yep, this has even been an issue during this series supposed "golden age". It's been nearly 20 whole years since NHL 07 released, and this is STILL an issue.

EA, if you do not fix this, then release it on PC so that the fans can do all the work you refuse to do.

2 Replies

  • Occam01's avatar
    Occam01
    Rising Novice
    27 days ago

    I’ve wondered about this too! The generated names are often so off, especially when they pull from totally random sources. It’s honestly pretty jarring to see a Polish player with a name like "Marshall Mathers" or something equally out of place. The whole bank system does need a major overhaul, and I totally agree with your FIFA comparison. It would be a huge improvement to see a more diverse and accurate naming system, or at the very least, additional region-specific banks to make things more authentic. 

     

  • MV75's avatar
    MV75
    Seasoned Veteran
    26 days ago

    And I do know that this have been a lot in the forums for many years. But EA NHL does not care, its not HUT....
    Its so stupid, because the solution is also so very easy to implement, all the names can just be copied from FC/FIFA database.....

About NHL 25 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around NHL 25 in the community forums.1,516 PostsLatest Activity: 2 hours ago