Be A Pro Goalie butterfly gap

I am playing as a hybrid goalie this year and while a skater is coming down the ice in the point, then takes a wrist shot/slap shot towards me that I can clearly see and have the proper time to go into the butterfly for. While going into the butterfly it looks like he jumps about a puck and a half width size up before coming down letting the puck go right underneath him 9.5 out of 10 times wether it’s the direct five hole or under his pads. I’m wondering if I’m the only one experiencing this or noticing this. Or is this a complete user error on my part. It has happened on hard to react to shots and shots that even my grandma could react to.  It doesn’t happen when the AI takes over for me dropping into the butterfly