I agree with all of these posts. I have been a loyal NHL fan since the 1997 version came out and with the exception of three versions of the game (99,09,13) I have owned every single version.
The first issue I would like to discuss is the skating. The last time I checked it doesn't take a hockey player half the width of the rink to turn, I recently played NHL 12 to see the difference between that game and 14. I was amazed at how much more control and how much quicker the players turned in NHL 12 vs NHL 14. And this is supposed to be the most "realistc" game? It makes the game very very frustrating to play when I try to manouver my player around the rink but it takes for ever to turn the player up ice. The best analogy I can make of this is, it's like turning a frieght ship on the ice as you need half the ice to make your turn.
My second issue revolves around the goaltenders. Yes once in a while a "soft" goal may go through a goaltender, however, the amount of goals that hit your tender and roll over his shoulder into the back of the net is ridiculas. Not to mention the ones that seem to slide under the tenders pads like he's 4 inches off the ice is madening. I will not go too much further in depth on this topic as the original post has made it very clear that the goaltending in future games needs to be addressed.
My final issue is with puck physics. I played 15 games in the span of three days with my brother and we purposly dumped the puck into corners to test a theory, and sure enough we found what we were looking for. Every time the puck gets dumped into a corner it jumps off the boards OVER players. Once again I do not remember ever seeing this happen in a real hockey game (realistic?). Not to mention how the puck bounces around like it is a lacrosse ball everywhere else on the ice just makes me shake my head.
I will say I have loved the additions to "Be a GM" mode, however unless these game play issues are resolved I do not know how I can ever justify spending my money on another version of this game again.