@-Roasted513- has a right to voice to his opinion on this forum, just as we have the right to cordially disagree with it. But it would probably be more helpful to suggest a solution rather than respond with a board comment of "Fix it". Because it's starting appear obvious EA doesn't seem to understand what is broken.
As @Katybee_1313 is stating it is currently working as designed in EA's eyes.
But @-Roasted513- is not wrong... overall the RNG is unbalanced. I believe there should be a small amount of RNG in play... but that shot execution should reflect the majority of the results shown in your shots.
I'm also okay with EA adjusting the RNG for certain shot types as they were overpowered and not realistic. Such as the Flopshot & Pickshot to name 2. EA could have also chosen to have an option to disable RNG for arcade players... but they didn't, so whose fault is that?
If posting raging comments puts the game in a better place, by all means rage away. We all choose whether or not to read them.