What occult should she be?

I like Fairies. I haven't played them too much though. :)

I picked fairy because it seems like a good choice for Elias. Second would be spellcaster. Haven’t really played vampires a lot, but plan to.

Just about any of them are a nice choice in 3, though witches are my favorite. I think vampire would be a nice contrast.

Vampire. I haven't played with vampires much. The first time I tried a vampire, I accidently killed it. :)

Here she is! And they've already felt a connection! Her name is Willow Rosethorne and she's a fairy(if the wings behind her didn't give you a hint. Lol)
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51461279540_36c7714584_h.jpg