Have you bought the Shamrock Cafe?

DannyTheElite wrote:
Shouldn't there be an option that says "I don't want him because I already have the wishing well"

Kind of the same thing as "No, as he does not have tasks". The wishing well leprechaun is basically the same as this one - so if you did buy it thinking he was a character - you'd see he has no tasks. Therefore if you regret the purchase of the well, then you aren't likely to get this diner at all - as the new "character" doesn't offer up any tasks - just like the leprechaun.