Volcano lair or duff brewery?

I got the brewery & Duffman early on, and have never regretted it because so many of Duffman's tasks are outdoors (love to see him riding the jet pack at the stadium, but you have to have the stadium) and the building looks pretty cool. The animation of the little mechanical man who comes out and drinks a Duff while the building's active is funny, too. I'd hoped it would open the door to getting other Duff stuff, like the Barney blimp and party bus, but I guess those were past limited time items.

I put off buying the Volcano Lair because it was so pricey, but finally went for it with Gil's discount donuts (the Christmas skin for it is what pushed me off the fence, I think) and now I wish I'd gotten it sooner. The Lair animation is great, and Scorpio has multiple outdoor tasks. It is a big 'building', but so is the brewery. I think it works fine right along the mountains at the edge of town.

Looking back, I'd put them about equal as far as adding fun and interest to my town. But I still probably would've gone for Duffman/brewery first just because he seems like a more 'must have' character to me. As someone else already said above, you should probably just go with whichever one you personally like better. :D