Ideas

mcj88's avatar
mcj88
Seasoned Newcomer
9 months ago

Multiple issues with create-a-team

NHL 24 added the ability to create up to 80 teams, so that's exactly what I did: enough to create a custom Franchise Mode with 40 NHL teams and 40 AHL teams. It was hard, and not just because it was obviously time-consuming, but also because of multiple bugs that impeded my progress. 

First, I learned the hard way that I had to keep every team's roster at the minimum 18 skaters and 2 goalies, because it seems the game has a hard cap on the total number of players that can be on created teams, and I don't believe that cap was increased when the number of teams one can create was increased from 50 to 80.
What I learned was that if you exceed that apparent cap, the game will remove the "excess" players from a team when you save it - and if that drops the team's roster below the "18 skaters, 2 goalies" minimum, it will display that team's overall as dangerously low, anywhere from 0 to ~25, and it will cause a corruption that crashes the game if you even scroll past that team on a menu; you can't even delete the team, you have to delete the roster file and start over.

Second, and the issue that brought me here today: even if you jump through that hoop and make the max number of teams, if you put them into a custom league (again, 40 NHL teams and 40 AHL teams), when you save, quit, exit the game, turn the Xbox off and come back later, anywhere from two-thirds to three quarters of the AHL are unplayably broken - their logos won't show up on the menus, and if you attempt to play a game with one of the broken teams, it just soft-locks while trying to load the team select screen.

And furthermore, the reason I'm bringing this up here & now is that both of these bugs carried over from NHL 24 to NHL 25 - when I downloaded a roster someone else made with 80 custom teams, it was afflicted with the corruption I mentioned, and when I made 80 bare-minimum teams myself & put them into Franchise Mode, the same exact thing happened where a large part of the AHL was unplayable; I even took a screenshot of it, which I've attached to this post. 

Is there anything y'all can do about this? Team/league creation is basically the one feature that keeps me coming back to these games, so when I can't get it to work correctly, it's extremely disappointing.

7 Comments

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    9 months ago

    Hey there. Thanks for all the feedback on this. I'm going to relay it to the team. I know we've had quite a few reports of issues with custom rosters. Hopefully, we can get those resolved in a future release.

  • mcj88's avatar
    mcj88
    Seasoned Newcomer
    9 months ago

    I would greatly appreciate that, thank you.

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    9 months ago

    You're very welcome. Thanks again for the report.

  • mcj88's avatar
    mcj88
    Seasoned Newcomer
    8 months ago

    I'm bumping this because I've discovered another layer to the first bug, the one I believe to be an issue of too many players being on created teams: after reporting this 2 months ago, I went back and downscaled my planned project, deleting the 40 teams I had planned for the AHL and only sticking to the 40 NHL teams for now, my theory being that I could still run full-sized rosters using that, and then make only the extra AHL teams I needed for a total of just 48, well within the limits of what even NHL 23 could work with - I know because I've done this in that game already. 

    Well, I don't know if it's an issue of the player cap I theorized about somehow being decreased between installments, or if it's an issue of deleted team rosters staying in memory for some reason, but now a little shy of halfway through maxing out every NHL team (on ~25 out of 40), I'm getting a problem where it just crashes instead of saving my roster changes. At first I thought it was a specific player causing the crash, but after some trial-and-error I found that was not the case - it would do it with different players as the last selected and different teams being selected from.

    (Please excuse the guerrilla-style camerawork in the example video, the console's own recording feature would just stop instead of showing the crash back to Home.) 

    (EDIT: first I attached the wrong video file, then my first attempt at linking it didn't work properly. I apologize for any inconveniences I've caused, but it's late, I'm tired, and frankly I'm mad about all the bugs I keep running into while trying to get a custom league going.)
    https://youtu.be/HTd8NYhQZnc

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    8 months ago

    Thanks for the update. I'll relay this to the team.

  • mcj88's avatar
    mcj88
    Seasoned Newcomer
    8 months ago

    After a bit more experimenting, I discovered that even if I deleted every single custom team, it would still consistently crash when trying to save a new created team; the only thing that "fixed" it was deleting the active roster file and creating a new one.

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    8 months ago

    That's good to know. Appreciate the update. Thank you.

Featured Places

Node avatar for NHL 25 Bug Reports

NHL 25 Bug Reports

Report bugs in NHL 25 in this community forum.Latest Activity: 2 years ago
753 Posts