Re: PS3 - Trophy / Platinum Problem
Okay, so I finally got this, but I don't think most people would have the luxury of the method that worked for me.
After everything failed on my own PS3, I used my parents PS3 (my PSN account is also active there as well, since I play there as well), started a brand new game (without update, and without expansions installed), and did it at their house. I still didn't get this until after I intimidated 15 people (everyone from the above list up to Carroll, and 2 others along the way that were not on the list above). Not sure where the actual glitch is, but maybe this can help someone somewhere along the line.