I think Dice should not listen to anyone and stick to who they are (If they still can) which is: a company that developed large scale vehicle+infantry combined arms FPS games.
The question is: do gamers still want that? If yes, then why so many players did not like the original Hourglass? Or why is Renewal, Exposure, Break Away etc not good for people?
I think those maps are everything that Battlefield stands for. What was the problem? The specialists? They got back almost all legacy features except the server browser. Would gamers like the original Hourglass if there would be a server browser in the game and proper factions? Honestly the original Hourglass was soooooo Battlefield for me.
Reclaimed, Haven, Stadium, even Redacted is sooooo COD. What gives? What do people want? Dice does not know anymore. As someone above said: they need to pick a lane.