Game Settings Keep Resetting

Try this @DaiusDreemurian 

1. On Home, select My games & apps.
2. Highlight the game, press the Menu button on your controller, then select Manage game & add-ons.
3. Select the Saved data box, you should see Battlefield 1 here. 
4. Delete it.

/Atic 

@EA_Atic I haven’t done it yet. I have discussed with other people on the subject, and I am worried that doing what you suggested (clearing local and online saves) will completely delete my in-game progress (weapon unlocks and Peacekeeper Easter egg progress specifically.) 

Is this the only way to solve this issue?

@EA_AticSo, I did do what you suggested. Oddly enough, the game said I had no save data, so I started the game, went through the intro yet again, and played multiplayer for a minute, which seemed to fix the issue, in which then I did what you told me to do and deleted the save data. Opened up the game, and it seemed like nothing had changed. Went through the intro AGAIN, exited the game, restarted it just to see if it was fixed, and… the same thing. I do not know what to do now, and I am worried my game is massively broken. Perhaps I do need to delete the game and reinstall? 

@EA_AticSo, I know it’s been a considerable while. Had life stuff, couldn’t get on my game to try the recommended fix (Delete and reinstall).
It didn’t do anything different. It might have gotten worse, actually? Seeing as I had to do the intro sequence, update the game, do the intro sequence again, and by then I gave up.
Is it the disk? The game’s code, my Xbox itself? I’m stumped, and disheartened, since this is my favorite game.

Edit: Oh. Also, all of my weapon unlocks have reset. I still have my skins, but all of my weapon progress? Gone. The game is acting as if I had never done them, even though I unlocked every single one…