Previous Play History Not Saving

I've had this glitch occur on both NCAA25 and now NCAA26, and for the life of me I can't figure out how to fix it.

Basically, when you play a game, regardless of mode, it won't track the results of the plays you call from game to game. For example, it might say I've called Nickle Load Double WR1 zero times for zero yards, and once I select the play and let it play out, the play art is updated to show I've called it 1 time for X yards allowed. However, when I finish that game and load up my next game, when I go back to that play it once again says I've never called it before and shows zero yards.

It took probably months of playing NCAA25 for this to occur, but on NCAA26 it happened like within a week of getting the game.